My Thoughts, as a Muslim, on the World Cup 2010 in South Africa

May 6, 2010 by Ismail Kamdar Sports, Health & Fitness
76 comments Tags: 2010 · Entertainment · football · soccer · South Africa · World Cup

Soccer's World Cup 2010 is just a few days away and for the first time the World Cup will be hosted by South Africa. This has led to much controversy amongst South African Muslims as to whether the World Cup is a good or bad thing and if it is permissible to watch it and support the team.

Many of the local scholars have taken the position that the World Cup is completely Haraam and evil and that all Muslims must boycott it. One of Durban's leading scholars Maulana Yunus Patel wrote a very strong article against the World Cup that has been distributed widely around the country. Other Du'aat however view this event as a great Dawah opportunity. Then there is a third group who are not interested in the religious rulings and are just excited to attend the World Cup matches live.

I must admit that I am a bit biased in this topic as I have never been a sports lover. However, I will not let that affect this article. I have to agree with Maulana Yunus Patel on some issues yet disagree on others. He is right in stating that many sins happen when these types of events take place including prostitution, intoxication and gambling, but I also have to admit that most of the Muslims who attend these matches do not get involved in these vices and are opposed to it.

The general ruling in Islam is that everything is permissible until proven Haraam. This applies to soccer and other sports as well. Watching or attending a soccer match would be permissible in and of itself but the ruling can change from individual to individual. The following are reasons that can make it Haraam for a person to watch soccer or any other form of entertainment:

1. If it causes one to miss a Salah. Salah is the single most important obligation in Islaam after upholding Tawheed. Anything which causes a person to miss a Salah would be Haraam for that individual to do. So if you want to watch any sport or attend an event, make sure to pray your Salah on time.

2. Indulging in or supporting the vices that occur at these places. No doubt that some people attending these events will be drinking, fornicating or indulging in other forbidden practices. If attending these events tempts one to commit these sins then such a person should stay away.

Besides avoiding temptation, it is also important to hate these sins and disapprove of them in one's heart. If one does so, then one can attend these events as you will not be responsible for someone else's actions at such events.

3. If it is not in excess or leading to wastage of time and money. Moderation is key for any form of entertainment to be permissible. One reason I dislike these sporting events is that people will miss Islamic events because these sports are more important to them, this attitude is not acceptable for a Muslim.

Also some people spend so much time engaged in watching these sports that they neglect their families, sometimes abuse them or waste a lot of money on the merchandise, which could be put to better use. So if one can balance watching these events with one's duties to Allah, one's family and oneself then it would be permissible.

4. If it leads to hero-worship. So many Muslims do not know the names or biographies of the heroes of Islam yet know the entire life stories of many actors, sports stars and musicians. This should not be the attitude of a Muslim. A Muslim should always give priority to Islam over all else. It is not prohibited to know these people's stories but when one gives preference to this over Muslim heroes, it may lead to idolizing these people and taking them as our role models which should not be the case for any Muslim.

If one has this attachment to these events and their stars, they need to realize that they are going down the wrong path and make a change. I do not mean that they should stop watching sports, but rather they should learn to balance and start making time to learn their religion, making that a priority in their life.

These are the most common reasons that can cause a sporting event to be prohibited, if one can overcome them then it can be permissible to attend and enjoy the match itself, and Allah knows best.

The other aspect of the World Cup is the Dawah opportunity. Many Muslims are complaining that the World Cup is a fitnah that should not happen in our country. There is nothing we can do to stop it, rather as Muslims we should be optimistic and look for some good in it that we can benefit from.

The thing I love the most about the World Cup is that it means many foreigners will be coming to our country. Many of whom may not have been exposed to Islam and are coming to a Western country in which Muslims are a very influential and powerful minority. This is a perfect opportunity to spread the message of Islam to thousands of people and reap the rewards thereof in the Afterlife.

So these are my thoughts on the topic, I will not be attending any matches but do not regrd it as Haraam in itself, but I am definitely planning a lot of Dawah activities for that time so that I may claim my share of the reward of spreading the message. What are your thoughts and views on such events?

Tags: 2010 · Entertainment · football · soccer · South Africa · World Cup

About MuslimMatters

Muslimmatters.org began in 2007 as a collaboration between various Bloggers and Shuyukh in order to bring attention to issues faced by Muslims, especially in the West. We have focused on issues of Religion, Society, Ethics, Sex Education, Politics, Civil Rights, Family, as well as the random issues that pop up from now and then, all with some ranting and humor mixed in.

We challenge ourselves and our readers to engage in discourses that touch our lives as citizens of the West, while maintaining our individual Islamic identities: Ultimately to cooperate, but not to compromise.

mofw

As always, glad to see that Muslims are not shying away from dealing with the pressing issues of the day.

Mumin

sarcasm

Gloria

I am torn but not because of the local scholars position as I agree with the author of this article. I love soccer and watching the world cup since I was a little kid, however, fifa banning the Iranian girl soccer team from playing in the olympics because of the hijab is the problem. On the one hand I love to see the world cup but it is part of FIFA on the other I feel like I have to support my sisters and NOT watch or buy anything related to fifa. AHH

UmA

http://ca.news.yahoo.com/s/capress/100503/sports/oly_soc_fifa_hijab_ban

http://www.muslimmatters.org/author/bushra Bushra

What a joke! They have to wear hats. What’s the point of playing in the first place?

elham

They’re thinking :” yes a hat, that looks more like what we would wear”.Ridiculous.

Middle Ground

Salam

What does Maulana Yunus Patel say about Hashim Amla and olther devout muslim cricketers, or cricket in general?

http://www.muslimmatters.org/author/bushra Bushra

Good point! Br. Hashim attends Al Kauthar courses in South Africa too, masha’Allah.

kaschif ahmed

As-salaamu alaykum,

The same should be said of the NBA Finals, NFL SuperBowl, NHL Stanley Cub, MLB World Series, Olympics, and others.

All four points happen.

But there is a greater threat than missing Salah, indulging of vices, laho (wasting time), and hero worship…

and this is putting one brother against the other..

As seen in America, I can’t say how it is in the other countries, but TEAM RIVALRY leads to one brother having love and/or hatred for another because of his home team.

It’s get’s so far that I don’t like him because he’s a ___ fan. Or he’s a ___ fan so me and him can relate.

I’ve heard people killing each other because of one or two calls in a game.

It is better for a brother not to show any favoritism for one or another team and watching (not playing) builds this love/hatred relationship.

Wa Allaho alim,

As-salaamu alaykum

http://islamiclearningmaterials.com Abu Ibrahim

That’s only in really extreme cases. My brother in law and I are both from New York City. He’s a Skankee…I’m sorry…Yankee fan, and I’m a Mets fan.

We rib each other about our respective teams, but it’s never gotten to the point of a full argument or even momentary hostility.

As with anything in life, moderation is key.

Keep sports in perspective, don’t waste too much time on it, turn off the TV when it’s time to pray, remember that it’s just a game.

And yes, Allah knows best.

Yaqeen needed

Abu Ibrahim

Just wondering aloud how you know ‘thatâ€™s only in really extreme cases’? if you do not have solid proof, then the anecdotal info available strongly supports Kaschif. The recent bitter fight between Egypt and Algeria surely cannot be forgotten. That is of course if you keep tabs with things outside the US

http://muslim-religion.net Abu Ibrahim

“That is of course if you keep tabs with things outside the US.”

Ah, such snide remarks. I’ll refrain from attacking you as you so subtly attacked me. I’ll remember the words of our Prophet (peace be upon him) who warned that a Muslim is one whom other Muslims are safe from their tongue and hands.

But, to counter your argument, one needn’t provide anecdotal evidence to prove that sports related violence is extreme. The definition of extreme is: “to the utmost degree.”

Obviously, sports related violence and bitterness are not the norm or it would happen most of the time around the world. It does not; not in the Muslim world or in the U.S.

The situation between Egypt and Algeria was an anomaly. It is an example of two groups taking their passion for a game to the extreme.

But it is not the norm. Therefore, YOU should provide the “anecdotal evidence” proving this sort of behavior is normal and typical.

Curious

Assalamu alaikum.

I am also a world cup lover. But the soccer dress is what worries me. Soccer players put on shorts that would leave open the lower portion of the thigh and the kneecap which are part of the ‘satr’ for males. Are muslims supposed to watch players in that dress given that it is not permissible to look at the awrah of other people?

Some one pls clarify on this dress issue so that we dont commit sins while cheering for our teams.

http://muslimmatters.org/author/amad/ Amad

Actually there is ikhtilaf whether the knee and thigh are parts of the man’s awrah or not.

On the knee, the stronger opinion is that it is not awrah: http://en.islamtoday.net/node/1119

With respect to thigh, difference of opinion

Ibn Hazm says: “It is correct to say that the thigh is not part of `Awrah, saying otherwise will conflict with the fact that Allah allowed His Prophet, who is protected (from sin), to uncover his thigh so that Anas and others could see it? Allah would have kept him from doing this. According to Jabir as recorded in the two Sahihs(authentic books of Al-Bukhari and Muslim), when the Prophet was young (before his prophethood), he was once carrying the stones of the Ka’bah, wearing only a loincloth. His uncle al-`Abbas said to him, ‘O nephew, why don’t you untie your waistcloth and put it on your shoulder for padding?’ The Prophet did so and fell unconscious. He was never seen naked again after that.”‘

[source]

Yaqeen needed

The question is not whether there is ikhtilaf. Its going into the sources before we can even say a position is stronger!!!

http://www.islam-qa.com/en/ref/34976/thighawrahmen
Yaqeen needed

The ahaadeeth supporting this position include:

1 â€“ Abu Dawood (3140) and Ibn Maajah (1460) narrated that â€˜Ali (may Allaah be pleased with him) said: The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: â€œDo not show your thigh, and do not look at the thigh of anyone, living or dead.â€

2 â€“ Ahmad (21989) narrated that Muhammad ibn Jahsh (may Allaah be pleased with him) said: The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) passed by Maâ€™mar when I was with him, and his thighs were uncovered. He said: â€œO Maâ€™mar, cover your thighs, for the thigh is â€˜awrah.â€

Commenting on these ahadeeth, Shaykh Albani said:

Although their isnaads are not entirely free of weakness, they strengthen one another, because there is no narrator among them who may be regarded as suspicious, rather their weakness has to do with confusion and ambiguity. And there are similar reports which make one confident that the hadeeth is saheeh, especially since some of them were classed as saheeh by al-Haakim, and al-Dhahabi agreed with him. And al-Bukhaari narrated it in a muâ€™allaq report in his Saheehâ€¦ But a number of these isnaads give the hadeeth strength, and raise it to the level of being saheeh, especially sincere there are similar, corroborating reports on the same issue. End quote.

And going beyond the fatwa and coming to reality, the shorts worn by these footballers and in other sports show more than the thigh. If you are in doubt and want to experiment whether such dressing are modest, according to the maqaasid of the sharia, get sisters to stare at what is brazenly shown in those shorts and ask them if they do not feel anything. Did the real salaf do this or look for opportunity to live their lives on the border line using the ikhtilaf flag?

http://muslimmatters.org/author/amad/ Amad

What I find it more brazen is that someone can promptly dismiss ikhtilaaf and set out to prove one opinion, essentially saying that the person knows better than the ulema who have had ikhtilaaf on this issue for centuries.

Since we are NOT scholars, it is sufficient to know that there is ikhtilaaf amongst the scholars of ahl sunnah on a particular issue. It is up to individual Muslims to follow opinions from the scholars they trust, or the madhab they adhere to. Which MEANS we respect the brothers who don’t hold the same opinion as us, and don’t go into a tear of haram and halal mini-fatwas.

If this post was meant to discuss the fiqh of awrah, we could bring in scholarly opinions to get into the details of it. But it is NOT. Let’s be more humble please.

P.S. I was not the one who made the conclusion about what the stronger opinion is, I was quoting the scholar from Islamtoday. I believe it is, but I will not judge others who don’t agree with me. wallahualam.

http://mezba.blogspot.com Mezba

“This has led to much controversy amongst South African Muslims as to whether the World Cup is a good or bad thing and if it is permissible to watch it and support the team.”

To those people: Please get a life.

It’s just a game. You watch the game and go home.
BintKhalil

Assalamu alaikum

Could you please consider posting another article detailing the kinds of da’wah activities that the South African Muslim community is planning? I think this is absolutely brilliant in that if the da’wah affects some of the visiting athletes who may have been nominal Muslims before or non-Muslim athletes learning about Islam who then perhaps start to talk positively about Islam, they could possibly influence the millions of adulating fans.
elham

On the issue of whether attending the games is halaal or haraam, doesn’t it also depend on why you’re there? I mean, some scholars say that travelling to a Non-Muslim country is haraam because of the same reasons mentioned in this article ( temptations etc) UNLESS its for da’wah, education, their health etc.

So can’t we also use this as an opportunity for da’wah and not anything else?
Abu Yunus

<>

Yes, when exactly will you have the opportunity to give da’wah? The people didn’t come to have a dialogue with people, they came to watch a soccer match. I don’t think the atmosphere would be conducive to give da’wah since their attention won’t be geared towards any person lecturing to them.

http://muslimmatters.org/author/ismail-kamdar Ismail Kamdar

These are tourists, many of them visiting SA for the first time. They are not just going to attend a soccer match then go home.

They will explore all the fun places here as well as our diverse mix of cultures and religions, including Islam since Muslims have a strong presence in the major cities. So it is when they are touring the country between soccer matches and observing Muslims and Masjids wherever they go, that is when Dawah opportunities arise.

By the way, Dawah is not just lecturing. There are many ways of doing Dawah, Masjid Tours, pamphlets, friendly chat, or even just showing good character. I’m thinking along those lines, not lectures.

http://brnaeem.blogspot.com naeem

AA-

You see, this is a perfect example of the problem I have with looking at social issues strictly from the fiqhi perspective (ie. is it halal or haram?). We’re missing the picture when we’re discussing men’s awrah or missing prayers. If we limit ourselves to such a tunnel vision, we overlook the greater evil that is inherent in the sports entertainment industry.

I see this multi-billion dollar industry as an extension of Hollywood and its ilk. What is essentially a commendable act (playing sports) has been transformed into a zombie-inducing form of entertainment. It is geared to dull the masses and re-direct their energies away from the real issues of the world.

Just like movies and TV shows, watching sports is about running away from the stresses of real life and temporarily entering a concocted world. Islam, on the other hand, is diametrically opposed to anything that distracts us from the realities of life.

I’ve written more on the sports industry being the new Opium of the Masses:
http://brnaeem.blogspot.com/2008/04/new-opium-of-masses.html
http://mezba.blogspot.com Mezba

Here is exactly what a non Muslim friend who read this piece commented to me.

“Why does no muslim ever come up with the notion to thank Allah for providing an excellent game like football, and just enjoy it and be grateful!
Sheesh!
No really, why are muslims always worried that fun things must be haraam, and why can’t they just have fun?
And if they want to be religious, why not have fun and thank Allah????
Who is Allah to Muslims? A loving God providing the good things in life, or a nasty practical joker and spoilsport?”

Yes. part of the comment may be blasphemous but think about it. What image are you projecting to people by even debating the halalness of watching the World Cup? What dawah? Seriously – those people who promote fatwas about World Cup being haram should just Get A Life. And they want to talk about Islam to people watching the world cup!!

I thought brother Naeem would perhaps provide a voice of reason but he has taken it to another level. I am glad to see Muslims are busy with the pressing issues of the day …

http://muslimmatters.org/author/amad/ Amad

Br. Mezba,
Our voice of reason is not calibrated by what non-Muslims think and feel about what Muslims find important to discuss. We may find the speaking of tongues in Evangelical prayers quite curious and even humorous, but I don’t find myself in a position to tell them “chill out guys, stop making funny noises”. I can understand non-Muslims not quite getting this, completely understandable. It is hard for them to understand a lot of things, including hijab, bathroom ettiquettes for Muslims, lack of Muslim dating, etc. That is why it is important to steer them away from such intricate issues and focus more on the big picture of Tawheed and the message of Islam in relation to the messages before.

You’ll find it interesting that non-Muslims mocked Muslims since the time that the Prophet(S) brought the message. One of the mushrikeen (polytheists) said to Salman al-Farsi rd, someone whose quest for truth took him many places: â€œYour Prophet has taught you everything, even how to defecate!â€ Obviously the person was trying to mock Islam. But did Salman rd shy away and make excuses for the deen. Nope. Salmaan said: â€œYes, he forbade us to face the qiblah when urinating or defecatingâ€¦â€ [Tirmidhi, Muslim]

http://www.muslimmatters.org/author/haytham Haytham

You see…. it is such “off the wall” articles about how haram and evil is soccer that make people look at us and be like what Mezba said…

No really, why are muslims always worried that fun things must be haraam, and why canâ€™t they just have fun? And if they want to be religious, why not have fun and thank Allah???

I understand the ‘awra part of it… and I understand the unreasonable time that some of us (including me) spend watching it and whatnot… but come on man … evil and haram? are you serious!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Yes we are governed by the Shari’a (our Quran and Sunnah) and yes not every thing accepted in this world is permissible in our religion…. yet equating zina to watching and loving soccer is, in my mind, purely insane!

peace

PS: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sXlBSlyU8xY <– its really true :)
Sayf

When you get a goal please don’t take your shirt off.
http://brnaeem.blogspot.com naeem

AA-

First of all, let’s be clear what I’m talking about here. I’m not denouncing cheering on your son in his soccer league or watching the local high school basketball game. I’m referring to the ridiculous industry that has been constructed around professional sports (amateur as well if you want to include the Olympics and college sports).

It boggles my mind how rational Muslims decry Hollywood and the extravagant lifestyle it projects, but find no grievance with the billions and billions of dollars wasted on stadiums, sports salaries, advertising, etc.

Both have taken legitimate forms of entertainment (sports and theatre) and transformed them into incredibly effective vehicles of distraction used to dumb down the masses.

Our deen calls us to make full use of all our faculties in combating the callings of our nafs as well as the machinations of our accursed enemy, Iblis. One of the reasons why drugs and alcohol are prohibited is because they dull our senses, rendering us weak in this battle against Shaytan and our nafs.

It is obvious to anyone who has participated as a die-hard fan of professional sports that it serves as an incredible source of distraction – the term ‘football widow’ illustrates my point.

These distractions serve to distant us from our primary objective of knowing, loving, and worshiping our Creator. What seems at the surface to be an innocent afternoon watching a game is in reality distancing us from our Lord in ways many of us cannot even comprehend.

Many may scoff at the laughable attention given to this ‘pressing issue’, but in reality what is more pressing than our relationship with our Lord?

That is why I believe we are missing the trees for the forest when we focus on peripheral issues such as gambling, drinking, gender-mixing, or missing prayers in the context of sports spectatorship. The real issue at hand is not whether watching the World Cup is halal or haram, but how it effects your relationship with Allah (swt).

http://muslimmatters.org/author/amad/ Amad

I agree and disagree. If Muslims were really practicing and staying away from major haraam, like drugs, sex, etc., then it would make sense that this would be a real distraction. But sometimes this distraction keeps them away from bigger sins, as is the sad affair of the Muslim today.

I think everything when done in due measure is okay… I watch cricket’s world cup quite closely. I am not infatuated or obsessed with it. But I do enjoy the thrills of winning, and the 5-minute sadness of losing. I don’t think it comes in the way of my relationship with Allah, because that would be an excuse, as I DO have quality time to create that relationship, and continue to fail. May Allah forgive me and help me build that.

http://brnaeem.blogspot.com naeem

“5-minute sadness of losing”

Say wha?! I don’t know a leg-spin from a googly and even I feel more than 5 minutes of remorse when Pakistan loses to India!! Man up and admit to the tears you’ve shed over the countless disappointments of the Pakistani team. :-)

Seriously, your argument about sports keeping youth away from bigger sins is valid (as I stated in my post), but it doesn’t fly here at MM, where most readers are a bit more religiously advanced.

My worry is that sports entertainment is seen as a ‘halal’ outlet, in contrast to the major sins, and so too many Muslims indulge themselves without moderation.

http://muslimmatters.org/author/amad/ Amad

I didn’t see loss to India… that’s a 7-day mourning period.

muslimah

haram to mourn for more than 3 days lol. but im so glad pakistan lost. way to go india !

http://www.roadtojannah.org Sulaiman

Bismillah,

Assalamu ‘Alaykum,

Jazak Allahu khayr for the interesting article brother. Just one thing to I noted, I think it should everything in mu’amalaat/dealings is halaal unless proven haraam and its vice versa for worship.

WAllahu Ta’ala A’lam

http://muslimmatters.org/author/ismail-kamdar Ismail Kamdar

Thank you for this correction, you are correct.

In terms of Dunyah, everything is Halal until proven Haram, in regards to Ibadah, everything is Bidah (innovation), until proven to be from the Sunnah.

Thank you for reminding me. :)

http://www.sagaciousmuslim.blogspot.com Sagacious Muslim

Salaam Alaikum

Someone commented on why something ‘fun’ would be haraam. Surely Islam does not forbid everything that is fun.

But- It should be noted that any act which creates “Fitnah” (meaning antagonism, war, riots, etc) is not recommended and therefore haraam.

A great example is the tension between Egypt & Algeria right now. Both are not only Arab countries, but Muslim nations as well. However, this desire to watch a fun football game has led to unfortunate violence & hatred from both sides of the conflict. The whole event was unnecessary & only slows progress between Muslim states in unifying with each other.

Such situations in the past has given the West a chance to invade & colonize similar nations at war with each other. Of course- may there be peace between Algeria & Egypt InshAllah. Neither people deserved this. The etiquette of Islam must prevail.

Watching soccer & cheering for your country is something fun, and it also promotes patriotism which is a good thing (especially if you do not have the luxery of living in your native country). But as soon as anything creates division & animosity, it would be less of a sacrifice & more of a return to just stay away from it.
http://muslimmatters.org/author/ismail-kamdar Ismail Kamdar

As Salaam Alaikum

Jazakallah Khair to all those who gave me positive yet critical feedback on this article. I was hoping to provide a different view on this issue and I pray and hope that this article has been of some benefit in showing the right to have fun in Islaam but the limits as well.

May Allah guide us to that which is best.
http://dreamlife.wordpress.com Dreamlife

To Naeem

I didn’t read your post (yet), but I agree with the essence of your argument – which is what a massive distraction all of this is.

In fact, there’s this Hamza Yusuf talk about Dajjal some time in the mid-90s (it’s quite long – and if anyone wants the link let me know); where he says – if i remember correctly – that the sports ‘industry’ is a big part of the system of Dajjal. It’s designed to delude us and take us away from what actually matters in the reality of things.

If you’ve seen the infamous “The Arrivals” series (which justfiably gets a lot of flack, but also contains some truth), near the end, there’s an epsiode about how we should be focussing on proper living – yet we’ve become distracted by so many other things that have taken on over-inflated importance in our world. (I think the episode is called ‘The Balanced Human’ or something). If i’m not mistaken, one image shown in that episode is of a crazy sports fan – as an illustration of how human passion, which should be used for PRODUCTIVE pursuits, has been diverted to artificial ’causes’ – such as supporting a sports team.

Some people have even gone as far as saying that the sport is their religion – and that attending games is their going to ‘church’.

While most of us aren’t that extreme – I think there’s a severe danger of many of us ending up that way, if we don’t curb our indulgence in such things and partake only in a balanced way. After all, we’d never openly admit to worshipping idols – but how many modern-day ‘idols’ are there in this world? Things that we pursue so enthusiastically – yet they aren’t really worth much in the bigger scheme of existence.

To those asking about da’wah:
Yes, people are coming with a mindset of relaxing, being entertained, and enjoying. But they’re still here as tourists – and as such, they’ll be touring. One initiative here in Cape Town is a tourist map which is part map, part da’wah material. There are also masjid tours planned for tourists, where they can come in, and Islam is explained to them.

A little while ago, Fadel Soliman (Bridges Foundation, Egypt) was in the country, conducting da’wah training in the World Cup cities.

And there are probably many more projects I haven’t even heard of…so there’s a lot, and we should support them; and not be sceptical.

We have dedicated da’ees and people involved in these activities – so insha-Allah all of this is going to be a success. And whether or not it has an effect on any tourists, that’s up to Allah. But as Muslims, we know that what we do is have te intention and make the effort – and the outcomes are in Allah’s hands.
Miro Bagrov

I am happy to see a muslim view of this event since I am assisting a business with WC10 plans.

I agree that it is very to consider and respect the views of both majority and minority to make this a fullfiling event for as many as possible.

Thank you for your post.
Kwame Madden

I hate to veer from the topic but the South Africian muslim community for yrs. neglected black population who suffered the most under apartheid.There was hardly any dawa that took place.All praise to Allah that in the last 15 yrs that has changed.Many of the indengious folks, at one time thought this was a religion for indians and malaysians.The hanif ulama are known for there strict strigent verdicts there in South Africa.It would be nice if they had just as much fervor in addressing issues like poverty, clean drinking water and decent wages for the poor.As far the World Cup goes we muslims should always seek moderation in all that we do.
http://dawahit.wordpress.com DawahIT

The bigger professional sports get, the less we play sports ourselves.

Just an observation.

Yaqeen needed

Its called deception and a lot seem to fall for it
Yaqeen needed

Fatwa on Football (soccer) competitions

http://www.islam-qa.com/en/ref/114530/football

farhan

Salaamualikum wr wb

No direct mention of the concept of Asabiyah. Curious to hear the author’s thoughts on how it relates to this subject, if at all.

JZK

Yaqeen needed

Another fatwa on soccer

http://www.islam-qa.com/en/ref/84291/football

Games between what is lawful and what is prohibited

http://www.islam-qa.com/en/ref/22305/soccer

One quote of importance

3 â€“ They should not take up a lot of the playerâ€™s time, let alone taking up all of his time or causing him to be known among the people for that, or becoming his job, because then there is the fear that the aayah (interpretation of the meaning) â€œWho took their religion as an amusement and play, and the life of the world deceived them. So this Day We shall forget themâ€ [al-Aâ€™raaf 7:51] may become applicable to him.

reality

I’d like to mention a few points that specifically apply to the majority of sporting events in N. America:

1) These events have open consumption of alcohol. People are drinking, getting drunk, screaming and all of this is very widespread.

2) There is open playing of music. Very loudly as well. Music is a key component to many of these events.

3) Almost all of these events have close to completely naked women dancing and entertaining the crowd via cheerleaders. This occurs at regular intervals and VERY frequently.

Thus, I can’t see how it can it be possible for anyone to allow any muslim to be in an environment. I would feel greatly ashamed to ever be caught in an event that was promoting such vices.

I think this sums up at least 50% of all sporting events.
http://www.twitter.com/AsiefD Asief

Salaam, as a South African I need to ask: since when do the aforementioned sins mentioned NOT happen in this country in any case? I fail to see how the World Cup is going to cause people to sin any more or less. People are already drinking, fornicating, etc here!

And before I get attacked, I’m not saying the world cup is good, I just want to know where the idea that it is inherently evil is coming from in the place.

Please don’t say it’s because more people coming in = more opportunity to sin. Because that’s a poor argument. Having beautiful mountains brings in tourists and those tourists are going to sin as much as they would at home, but if you tell me the mountain is evil, well then I have no words for you.

Looking forward to your (non-aggressive) response.

Shukriya,
Asief
Cape Town, South Africa

another white brother

People are already going to drink in bars or act liciviously in strip clubs. Is it permissible to go to either, even if one doesn’t partake in the haraam while there?

http://www.twitter.com/AsiefD Asief

There seems to be a lack of congruency between what we think the issue is. My point is about whether the world cup in itself is evil, like I said those people are going to do their thing but that’s none of my business is it.

another white brother

Actually, it kinda is. Enjoining the good, forbidding the evil and all.

sumaiya

Assalamu Alaikum,

The world cup is a waste of money.There are millions of people in south africa who are homeless and starving.If the SA government spent more time and effort sheltering and feeding these homeless people their would be less crime.millions spent on the world cup what a shame…..millions dying of hunger
People spend thousands purchasing world cup tickets…..some of them consider this as a once in a lifetime opportunity…..ask them if they performed Hajj?……the reply is No!……they would rather attend a match then perform Hajj…..Allahu Alam

Wassalam
anooonymouse

Firstly, the first two opinions are not mutually exclusive. Maulana Yunus is not saying to not perform da’wah!

Secondly, regarding the matter of inherent permissibility, there really isn’t even an honest question there for people of taqwa (basic question of awrah, cheerleaders, sitting in a company where haraam is committed, etc. all matters that remove the question of permissibility beyond a shadow of a doubt).

But even beyond that fact there is a much more dangerous delusion that this writer is laboring under. He goes to great lengths to describe what, in his opinion, WOULD make the world cup haraam- he mentions 4 things. Then he acts as if those things are the “exception to the rule” among people. I mean could you be more delusional about your own condition or the condition of the public? Is there a SINGLE fan of the world cup that is not committing one or more of those things? But the articles is very subtly written in order to give the impression that this is something extraordinary for a Muslim fan to be engaging in these haraam aspects, and as if it is possible to be a “fan” and not do so.

I mean who will attend and then hate the haraam that is going on? If you truly hated it, you would rather not attend since there is no necessity. Who will watch the matches and not hero-worship the sports idols? And when is it NOT a wastage of time and money, given the hours long matches every day, when there are more beneficial, and more entertaining means of keeping your family happy and together? Is there a single fan that has enough time to watch for 3 or 4 hours (I’m not sure how long these things go on) and pray all their salaah, and read their daily qur’aan, and fulfill the rights of their family, oh, and don’t forget that the vast majority of Muslims have not learned the faraaidh knowledge of Islam, so they would also be required to spend their free time doing that, etc. etc. etc…..

Ø§Ù„ØÙ…Ø¯ Ù„Ù„Ù‡, the scholars like Hazrat Maulana Yunus Ø¯Ø§Ù…Øª Ø¨Ø±ÙƒØ§ØªÙ‡Ù…, have their fingers on the pulse of the Muslim society, by Allah’s grace, and by their answering 100′s of cases of Muslims all over the world in all kinds of spiritual illnesses daily. Therefore, when they give advice it is based on the reality of the condition of the human nafs, and their own experience in bringing it under control and self-purification.

These bloggers that are for some reason being looked towards for ruling by some Muslims are themselves unable to control their nafs, look around for justification, then they feel the need to justify themselves with the world as well, and then they end up misleading other people that are laboring under the same spiritual ills.
This is nothing but self-deception and delusion.

http://muslimmatters.org/author/ismail-kamdar Ismail Kamdar

I did not disrespect Maulana Yunus Patel anywhere in my article, I even called him ‘One of Durbanâ€™s leading scholars’ rather I disagreed respectfully.

So why in response do you feel the necessity of stooping to personal attacks and name-calling, statements like “These bloggers that are for some reason being looked towards for ruling by some Muslims are themselves unable to control their nafs, look around for justification, then they feel the need to justify themselves with the world as well, and then they end up misleading other people that are laboring under the same spiritual ills. This is nothing but self-deception and delusion.” are uncalled for and insulting, please maintain Islamic Adab when presenting an opposing view.

To generalize that everybody who watches soccer must be involved in these sins is a major generalization and unislamic, I know many people who just watch the matches, enjoy it and that is all they do without getting involved in the sins others are doing. By that analogy, going anywhere for fun would be Haraam, since at every beach, shopping centre or park, you will find women dressed immodestly, music and people drinking.

For your information, I dislike soccer and won’t even watch a single match at the World Cup, so I never write this article to satisfy my Nafs, rather the view I presented goes agianst my desires.

anooonymouse

You simply repeated the same delusion, in spite of the fact that I gave specific examples.
My statements may be a major generalization, but that does not make them any less based in fact. Again, I say, for example, “Is there a single fan that has enough time to watch for 3 or 4 hours (Iâ€™m not sure how long these things go on) and pray all their salaah, and read their daily qurâ€™aan, and fulfill the rights of their family, oh, and donâ€™t forget that the vast majority of Muslims have not learned the faraaidh knowledge of Islam, so they would also be required to spend their free time doing that, etc. etc. etcâ€¦..” The same holds true of the other harms. And any individual that is not getting involved in all but one of the haraam things, will still be involved in that one, and that is sufficient.
Also, this, second article describes the issue from another angle and the injustice which those who support this event are involving themselves in.

After berating me for making a generalization, you then made one of your own: “at every beach, shopping centre or park, you will find women dressed immodestly, music and people drinking.” To which I reply, that this is generalization is not based in fact because of two factors:
(a) Those are not the only sources for fun. If it were really true that this was the case, there should be no difficulty for a Muslim to give these things up and adopt other sources for fun that don’t have those problems.
(b) There are times, locations, and days when all those things may be visited when there will not be any of those haraam things happening, for example, early in the morning after fajr, at more remote areas of the beaches and parks, during the off-season, etc.

Ahmad

Your “Hazrat Maulana Yunus” is not a scholar. He is a Sufi spiritual leader – by no means a scholar. One wonders why he and his followers are not as critical of cricket as they are of soccer. Could it be because Hashim Amla is one of his flock?

anooonymouse

I’m afraid you are severely mistaken on 4 out of 5 accounts.

(1) He is a scholar. He has ijaazah from Darul Uloom Deoband. In fact, he was the chairman of Jamiat Ulema KZN for many years before he resigned due to poor health.

(2) He is a Sufi spiritual leader, alhumdulillah. He has khilaafat from two of the great awliyaa of our time.

(3) He has spoken similarly about cricket matches many a time. Why have you made this unbased accusation? If you knew the slightest bit about him, in fact, if you had listened to only a few of his lectures, you would never have said such a stupid thing.

(4) He is not critical of soccer. He is critical of this professional soccer (and professional cricket) opium of the masses. Obviously, if you want to play a game of soccer on your local field, there is no harm in that.

(5) I don’t know who this Hashim Amla character is, but obviously our Shuyookh do not turn anyone away that comes to them for rectification. Do you think they check if each person is a wali first before accepting their bay’ah? Obviously, there are people who drink, people who gamble, etc. among his “flock”, if they didn’t have spiritual ills that needed rectification, they wouldn’t need him.

You should be more careful about statements you make with ignorance about the awliyaa of Allah. Allah himself does their protection.

A Janjua

May I ask how you determine who the awliyaa of Allah are?

May Allah beautify our charcacters, ameen.

anooonymouse

By how strictly they follow the sunnah in their own lives, by their encouragement of others to follow the sunnah, by their sticking by the Shariah even when it may be unpopular with their “fan base,” by the condition of their graduated students in all of the above…..

…..etc.

lily

I like the view put by Idris Tawfiq in his article about soccer here : http://www.idristawfiq.com/index.php?news=113
Riz Malek Luton uk

It’s very simple, you cannot watch footy as their are 23 naked men running around on the pitch. Their suttar is not covered I.e their shorts are above their knee. So according to sharia they are not covered. Simples. So now ask yourself, does Islam allow us to see other peoples uncovered suttar…….. And theirs your answer. = )

sabirah

i just ordered all possible sky sports channels, and i don’t intend to just listen to the horns overpowering the commentator :)

http://diaryofamuslimgirl.blogspot.com Muslim Girl

If the sports industry is designed to delude us and take us away from what actually matters in the reality of things… you guys just totally fell into the trap since you have spent so much time and effort talking about something so useless when a much more eminent issue could have been discussed.

Like, REALLY, guys? SOCCER???

anooonymouse

Doing something haraam == talking to other to get them to stay away from haraam?

You think giving advice and warning to others to stay away from useless things is a waste of time? Seems like a very good use of time to me.

sabirah

salam
as an alternative to discuss if soccer is compatible with Islam we could share a thought or two about the brothers and sisters in Kyrgyzstan where muslims are killing muslims … which I think is more worth pondering.

anooonymouse

The two discussions are NOT mutually exclusive.

Middle Ground

Salam

In Somalia, people are getting murdered for watching the World Cup:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/world/africa/10307512.stm

Subhanallah… watching soccer is haram, but killing your muslim brother is halal. And we want to tell the whole world about what a great religion Islam is….

another white brother

Got any *real* proof for that statement? I have personally seen incidents where BBC has lied on muslims and never retracted statements. That makes them daeef.

Very Sad

Salam

It happened famously in Somalia in the last world cup as well. 10 Somalians were killed in a cinema for watching.

http://muslimmatters.org/author/amad/ Amad

I wonder about such stories considering how bad they sound. I mean any Muslim with basic beliefs can understand that you can’t hurt someone, let alone kill someone because of watching soccer. I wonder if the deaths occurred as part of another agenda, with soccer as an excuse.

On the other hand, it is one of the signs of khawarij is that their utter disregard for Muslim blood. But I do doubt that there are very many Somalians who would consider such action.

I think the lawless situation of Somalia is allowing jaahil people to do crazy things in the name of their political cause, and as always masked in religious language.

It’s tough to blame the Islamophobes when we keep gifting them such awful stories.
elham

La hawla wa la quwata illa billah. The people have only Allah(swt).They know enough to see that these nutjobs’ actions are alien to Islam.

Once one man’s blood is spilled with no remorse,the rest is a reptition of the same and every episode finds its excuse to occur.They do not avoid bloodshed they seek it.
anooonymouse

If you will watch the world cup under threat of flogging, then I’m pretty sure that’s a sign of “excess”, one of this ^^ guy’s 4 points.

Middle Ground

Salam

And you’ll be ready with the whips?

http://muslimmatters.org/author/ify-okoye/ Ify Okoye

This just in: the World Cup prayer space is sunnah-style and barrier-free. And there is a separate women’s tent for those who wish to pray by themselves.

anooonymouse

“Sunnah-style” AND barrier free….

Interesting….

http://muslimmatters.org/author/ismail-kamdar Ismail Kamdar

Latest conspiracy theory about the World Cup. The Mascot of the World Cup is a cute animal named Zakumi which stand for SA 2010, however many local Muslims are convinced it is named after a tree in Hell named Zarqoom. I even heard a Moulana warn against Zakumi on this argument in the Jumah Khutbah,
http://www.twitter.com/AsiefD Asief

I just lol’d

But sometimes I don’t know who to blame for this. There are people who believe they’re doing Islam a favour by spreading conspiracies based off lies, but at the end of the day it’s just that: lies! On the other hand, it’s like the youth here in SA only take a moral stance on something when somebody sensationalises the issue with a conspiracy eg: The Arrivals series had everyone all of a sudden “open their eyes”…. For like two minutes that is.

An example would be the way I try to get my family to boycott Zionist products. They never listen, they have no problem supporting the firms who finance the slaughter of Palestinians but when someone forwards an e-mail saying that if you turn a bottle of Coca Cola upsidedown the text actually says there is no Allah or somesuch crap or that Mc Donalds coats their chips in pig fat, THEN they’re quick to abandon the products…. For like two minutes that is.
Khaliq.Bux

In The Name of Allah, The Most beneficient, The Most Merciful.
â€œInvite (all) to the Way of your Rabb (Cherisher and Sustainer) with wisdom and beautiful preaching; and argue with them in ways that are best and most gracious: for your Rabb knows best, who have strayed from His Path, and who receive guidance.â€ (16:125)

Abu Hurairah (RA) narrated that the Prophet (SAW) said, â€œReligion is very easy and whoever overburdens himself in his religion will not be able to continue in that way. So you should not be extremists, but try to be near to perfection and receive the good tidings that you will be rewarded; and gain strength by offering the prayers in the mornings, afternoons and during the last hours of the nights.â€ (Bukhari 1/ 38)

â€œ…O my Rabb! Expand me my breast. Ease My task for me; and remove the impediment from my speech, so they may understand what I say.â€ (20:25-28)

â€œO my Rabb (Cherisher and Sustainer)! Bestow wisdom on me, and join me with the righteous; grant me honorable mention on the tongue of truth among the latest (generations); make me one of the inheritors of the Garden of Bliss.â€ (26:83-84)

Ismail Kamdar

About MuslimMatters

Awards

Social networks