#Culture
Welcome to Islam, Now Shut Up
Enemy turned friend, cynic turned believer, doubt turned to conviction. There is something compelling about a powerful convert story. It speaks of the transformative nature of faith, and to the laymen it is a testimony to the truthfulness of the religion now adopted. A sworn enemy of a faith suddenly joining it is a testimony of its power, and the only way it could do that is if it is the truth. This is an appeal that not only Islam but all religions use. That was what made Paul of Tarsus’ conversion so compelling to Christians. But with any powerful proselytizing tool, here come the insincere ready to misuse it for their own gain.
And oh, how there are many of them.
For the last couple of years, populist grifters along the political spectrum have been turning Muslim or feigning interest in Islam. This is of course welcomed, as anyone who accepts Islam cannot have their faith rejected. What isn’t acceptable is the susceptibility of Muslims who drool over these newcomers, pushing them towards speaking up about Islam. Some don’t even have to be pushed, electing themselves to represent Islam prior to even learning how to do wudu.
The Islamic scene today already has issues with born-Muslims speaking on behalf of Islam without the proper credentials, experience, or wisdom needed to carry the mantle of din. In the Muslim World with all the problems that exist, even the simpleton from the village knows not to elect the aspiring hafiz to speak on matters of the din. I experienced this first hand as a wide-eyed 18 year-old Canadian spending his first summer in Afghanistan. As passionate as I was, everyone would refer to me as a “chali” which was the word used for the masjid imam’s assistant. It annoyed me at the time, but thinking back I appreciate that world better than what we have today.
Keep supporting MuslimMatters for the sake of Allah
Alhamdulillah, we're at over 850 supporters. Help us get to 900 supporters this month. All it takes is a small gift from a reader like you to keep us going, for just $2 / month.
The Prophet (SAW) has taught us the best of deeds are those that done consistently, even if they are small. Click here to support MuslimMatters with a monthly donation of $2 per month. Set it and collect blessings from Allah (swt) for the khayr you're supporting without thinking about it.
With online influencers, it isn’t just the case of the zealous convert becoming too excited to stop himself from speaking of their new faith; it’s the fact that the convert may not be zealous at all but simply feigning it. Although we cannot be sure of this, I admit, there are telling signs that a lot of grifters are simply using their Muslim audience: either to push an agenda, to make a quick buck, to have their “come-to-Islam” moment and clean their prior image, or because they sincerely believe but want to maximalize the opportunity afforded to them (just like the “dawah bros”).
Now, before I break down why I believe this is the case, I’m going to answer a common objection that you hear when you bring up these concerns. The first of these being that we cannot doubt anyone’s Islam when they become Muslim, and the second that we should have husnal-zhan (good assumptions) with our Muslim brothers and sisters and not be so cynical in thinking that they have ulterior motives entering the din.
It’s not difficult to understand that whoever professes the two testimonies of faith are Muslim. This entry into the din is a matter of conviction (يقين , yaqin) and therefore to take someone out of the religion can only be done through the same level of conviction. So unless someone says they have left the religion very explicitly or denies clear beliefs from the Quran and Sunnah or holds beliefs tantamounting to explicit shirk and kufr, after many exhaustive measures are taken, you cannot take one out of the faith.
“I do not deem an unbeliever anyone from the Ummah.” – Imam Taqiuddin Ahmad ibn Taymiyya
All of the issues that I’ve stated, even those that show clear duplicity, do not take one out of Islam. However, even if that is the case, nor does entering Islam guarantee sincerity. Just because someone becomes Muslim it doesn’t mean we put blinders on and forget about their past. Not only is there nothing from the Prophet Muhammad or the Sahaba that indicate that we do so, they have shown the direct opposite; expiated sins does not infer a completely new human being. Even the many sahaba who were once enemies of Islam understood this, feeling that they had to make up for their past sins by exerting the same effort in supporting the religion the same way they did against it.
Take for instance in the end of Surah Mumtahanah, Allah tells the Prophet ﷺ to take a vow from newly converted Muslim women that they will not do a series of acts that they used to before.
“يَـٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلنَّبِىُّ إِذَا جَآءَكَ ٱلْمُؤْمِنَـٰتُ يُبَايِعْنَكَ عَلَىٰٓ أَن لَّا يُشْرِكْنَ بِٱللَّهِ شَيْـًٔا وَلَا يَسْرِقْنَ وَلَا يَزْنِينَ وَلَا يَقْتُلْنَ أَوْلَـٰدَهُنَّ وَلَا يَأْتِينَ بِبُهْتَـٰنٍ يَفْتَرِينَهُۥ بَيْنَ أَيْدِيهِنَّ وَأَرْجُلِهِنَّ وَلَا يَعْصِينَكَ فِى مَعْرُوفٍ ۙ فَبَايِعْهُنَّ وَٱسْتَغْفِرْ لَهُنَّ ٱللَّهَ ۖ إِنَّ ٱللَّهَ غَفُورٌ رَّحِيمٌ ١٢
O Prophet! When the believing women come to you, pledging to you that they will neither associate anything with Allah, nor steal, nor fornicate, nor kill their children, nor falsely attribute [illegitimate] children to their husbands, nor disobey you in what is right, then accept their pledge, and ask Allah to forgive them. Surely Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful.” (60:12)
We also see this clearly in the case of the sahaba. One notable example is of the Sahabi Suhail ibn Amr. The story goes that one day senior sahaba were waiting by the door of caliph Umar bin al-Khattab along with notables of the Quraish but instead of first addressing the notables of Quraish he first addressed the senior sahaba. Some Quraish notables were angered, to which Suhail bin Amr told them that they shouldn’t be upset: while they had been slow in answering the call to Islam, the senior sahaba were fast.
Suhail then proclaimed: “By Allah I will not leave a single stance that I took alongside the polytheists except that I take an equivalent stance alongside the Muslims, and whatever I have spent on the polytheists I will spend the like of it upon the Muslims” (2). You find similar statements almost verbatim from Ikrimah bin Abi Jahl (3) and Abu Sufyan (4). It is no surprise that all of them died as martyrs in lands far from their birthplace of Mecca.
Wahshi ibn Harb used his spear for good after having used it for evil (image: Deutschland Digital Museum)
Another example is that of Wahshi bin Harb who was the one who killed Hamza, the uncle of the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ. Even after he turned Muslim, and the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ accepted his Islam, he still felt he had to make amends. So when the opportunity came to fight the False prophet Musailama the Liar, he took it. He quite literally said “I will make amends for what I did to Hamza” (5). Then at the moment that he threw his spear, an Ansari (some say Abdullah ibn Zaid, whose brother Habib had been treacherously tortured to death by Musailama) also swung his sword at Musailama. “If I did kill him,” Wahshi said of the slain Liar, “then after the advent of the Messenger of Allah ﷺ I have killed the best of men and the worst of men.”(6)
The moral here is that even though Wahshi’s Islam was accepted by the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) and he was forgiven, he still felt that he had to make amends for what he had done against Islam prior to his conversion. May Allah be pleased with them all.
Many brothers who defend clickbait grifters know this very well, yet I believe they use them to make the grifters feel safe with an implicit understanding; as long as you push Islam (or our version of Islam that gives us control) then we will give you the necessary stamp of approval with all the Islamic arguments you need.
The audience, however, aren’t aware of these implicit understandings, they fall for the bait hook-line-and sinker and once the grifters get what they’ve come for they begin to reveal their true nature. Sometimes that nature is that they are actually heretical or feigning piety; other times they show true hypocrisy by pandering to their other constituents, such as white nationalists or conservative parties, even if it’s at the expense of Islam. Through all this, the “Dawah” Mafia gift the lightest reprimands and brotherly advice to the grifters that they never share with Muslim interlocutors that don’t share a quarter of their betrayal and duplicity.
There are three things to understand going forward.
- What is a Grifter?
But what is a grifter? Where does the word come from? In brief, a grifter is someone who lies for money by manipulating the audience he’s trying to scam. Grifters mostly show themselves as something that they are not, such as an expert. This expertise could be in something professional, recreational, humanitarian or academic. They prey on their audiences lack of knowledge and self-esteem, void in themselves. Sometimes they have the credentials, but simply exaggerate their level at it and sell something to the audience they think they need. This is usually manifested in book sales but in these days it’s sold in courses and sometimes, building projects that never come into fruition.
Does this mean every course sold is a grift? No of course not. Does that mean every Muslim who tries to sell a course is a grifter? No, not necessarily. If they are not lying and being truthful then it’s not a grift, it’s just a rip off. If you’re being convinced that you need to go on expensive trip with the boys to shoot guns and ride horses all while gaining (superficial) knowledge then you may not be getting grifted but you’re definitely being scammed or at least ripped off.
Not every scam is a grift but every grift is a scam.
- It’s all Wrestling
The recent slew of converts aren’t just bringing grifters, they’re bringing a worse set of people; pundits. Oh yeah they may not grift in the modern sense but they are from the same ilk through-and-through. Pundits, especially in America and the general West, consistently change sides in order to garner an audience, and to that audience instead of selling a course or a special branch of knowledge they regurgitate what they know their audience will like to hear. This is a spectrum, some are in it for what they feel is the right side. They want to bring change or push their side no matter what. Others simply move to what is popular or where they can gain popularity. Think of all the POC’s that became republicans/conservatives or MAGA. In a sense, the ex-muslim movement was a subset of these people.
FD Signifier, a popular commentator of African-American social issues on YouTube, recently made a video talking about the history of Wrestling entertainment and the special relationship between the Iron Sheik (pronounced sheek instead of sheikh) and Jim ‘Hackthesaw’ Duggan (7). Now a little history about WWF (now WWE): though we now know that it is fake, back in the 1980s the feuds and fights were portrayed as being real, and people actually believed it.
Until the day the scarily foreign Iron Sheik and the all-American hero Hacksaw were caught with marijuana by a cop. It was exposed that they were actually friends and their whole feud, essentiall,y an act. Understand, this is like seeing the most staunch Salafi Madkhali laughing and joking with the most Sufi Zaytuna/Safina society imam you could think of. Or, for the British folk, like going to Birmingham and seeing a Barelwi Sheikh break bread with an Imam from SPUBS. It would rattle the mind. This devastated the Wrestling world, but then eventually most people accepted the storylines as just part of the entertainment and enjoyed it for what it was. Some people in the wrestling fandom, known as “Marks”, still actually believe it was real.
FD signifier argues that this is the case with political pundits today, we are essentially Marks falling for the act. The sign of this is how easily these pundits sway between the political aisle. Take for instance Candace Owens, who was a Democrat liberal when she first started out but turned hard towards Conservativism, even at the expense of her own community and eventually becoming part of and then discarding MAGA. She now peddles conspiracy theories to a new audience and is aligned more with the groypers. This is a constant phenomenon, and it’s not all about money. Take Elon Musk, who was liberal until he eventually went far-right. His isn’t a case of needing money, of which he has plenty, but a vain, incessant desire to be accepted.
Audiences are becoming much more attuned to the act. Informed and critical thinkers, regardless of faith, can detect patterns and understand the game being played. Yet there are others, to continue the analogy, being played. FD Signifier argues this is due to “Marks” wanting their fantasies to be real because deep down they actually hate themselves. I’d say they are lost, and feel disenfranchised. It’s not just white men who may be complaining about why they aren’t winning, a major factor in Trump’s support base, but also other disenfranchised groups that feel the same way. Keep in mind that marginalization and disenfranchisement doesn’t have to be real, it just has to feel real to the person.
Speaking of which…
Dave Chappelle in 2000
- Bringing it back to the Muslims
Muslims all over are being grifted. It’s not only Western Muslim men, it’s not only women, it’s all over the world. Muslims feel attacked, lost, and purposeless. Even when they find faith, the overwhelming hatred and vitriol aimed towards us, often from each other, makes us look for hope wherever we can find it.
From a group of these people rise sincere believers whose take up the mantle but become their own versions of grifters and pundits. It’s the nature of the medium, it’s hard to play the game and not become the character that you portray. This article is less of an indictment on pundits and grifters entering Islam and using it; they are just playing to their nature. It is the fact that the real shortcomings of Muslims are being exploited to garner an audience, the mere presence of which produces the long sought out desire for income and notoriety. That hope and desire for a champion is what ultimately pushes Muslims to platform people who should be as far away from a platform as possible.
The world is a mess, and we are angry. We come online fighting and tearing into each other as a means of catharsis. Our leaders are meant to protect us from this, but you find that these two groups of grifters and pundits are of one kind, regardless of faith. Which is why you find, as I said before, the “Dawah” mafia constantly treat those with a platform, regardless of how they attained it, with utmost care. At the end of the day, it’s all political. Gaining influence no matter who has it is the most important thing.
To be fair to “Dawah” Inc., this was actually set up by our predecessors. Prior to this era we did it with celebrity converts, but these at least were people who honestly just wanted to worship. So their stories and conversions were used as simple “Rapper A and Singer B are Muslim and here’s why” and that was that; these brothers and sisters mostly chose to keep their faith private. An illustrative story that I heard from a trustworthy brother concerns the comedian Dave Chappelle. He was seen by a group of brothers in Madinah who started badgering him for a picture to which Chappelle politely told them to leave him alone because he wanted to worship Allah.
You find this constantly with artists from areas of the entertainment world, often African-American artists who are Muslim, and who do not express their faith, except perhaps briefly in their art, or keep it completely private (8). When asked why they don’t talk about Islam they always say that they don’t want their actions to be associated with Islam.
Islam is not just a faith we profess; the shahada enters us into the faith but does not complete it. It does not require us to be blind and oblivious to the realities of the world; nor does Islam state that professing it wipes away personality traits and bad habits. In order for Muslims to avoid falling prey to the lure of fame with influencers, grifters, and pundits, they require deep internal reformation that can only be achieved through personal, spiritual work and spending time with true scholars and teachers.
This requires an exertion to break free from societal, economic and political chains that binds down the people, pushing them towards sheepitude. Or, if they can’t break from it, overcome it even in their unchangeable state. Many of the sahaba were poor and stayed poor. Many of them had no way to leave Makkah even when they wanted to. This is a harsh pill to swallow but Islam is liberating even for the downtrodden. I’ve seen Muslims all over the world that accept this reality, yet simultaneously are no less hardworking in trying to improve their lot.
To the Muslims who know all this, but see the exploitation of this class as a means to an end, know that dishonesty never wins. When Muslims try to dupe and manipulate people into the faith, we do Islam a disservice. Eventually many of those people will see the truth of grifters and disregard any person, no matter how sincere and honest, who invites them to Islam. I witnessed this first hand in the mid-2000s with the “scientific miracles” arguments that used to make the rounds in the early days of the internet.
To this is the olive branch I always extend to the new converts with a platform. Get off social media, forsake your old ways of jahiliyya and undergo tarbiyya (self-improvement). Seek knowledge and work on yourself. Try to make an honest wage. Don’t speak publicly, it’s better for you, but if you must speak only do so when your faith is anchored and you can ensure your sincerity. I’ve been told that Sheikh Ali Hani said, “Whoever speaks about Islam while not observing the night prayer, it is as if his words enter one ear and exit the other. As for the one who speaks about Islam and observes the night prayer, his words exit from one heart and enter into the other” (9)(10).
This advice of course goes out to many Muslims, but the temptation for you is far more pertinent. Islam should be treated and promoted with the respect and reverence it deserves, and that simply appears first in your heart before it appears on your tongue.
A special thanks to brother Ibrahim Moiz for help editing and giving feedback and also to brother Zubayr for bringing to my attention key passages and quotes.
Sources:
1) Surah Mumtahana 60:12
2) Suhayl bin Amr: https://app.turath.io/book/12823?page=5022
3) Ikrimah: https://app.turath.io/book/2266?page=5413
4) Abu Sufyan: https://app.turath.io/book/21723?page=29
5) https://sunnah.com/bukhari:4072
6) https://dorar.net/h/Sd1e5k9J?osoul=1
7) https://youtu.be/v4DpWMjg4p0?si=D1W0Q_aYs5QK41iC (FD signifier: I’m done with political commentators)
8) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C3tei0QOzGA (celebrity black muslim meet up)
9) Qawl of Shaykh Ali Hani: ان الانسان اذا كان داعيا دون قيام الليل، كلامه يدخل في الاذان يخرج من الاذان، اما اذا اقام الليل كلامه يخرج من القلب الى القلب
10) Imam Razi had similar sentiments in his tafsir:
﴿أَوۡ زِدۡ عَلَیۡهِ وَرَتِّلِ ٱلۡقُرۡءَانَ تَرۡتِیلًا﴾
واعْلَمْ أنَّهُ تَعالى لَمّا أمَرَهُ بِصَلاةِ اللَّيْلِ أمَرَهُ بِتَرْتِيلِ القُرْآنِ حَتّى يَتَمَكَّنَ الخاطِرُ مِنَ التَّأمُّلِ في حَقائِقِ تِلْكَ الآياتِ ودَقائِقِها، فَعِنْدَ الوُصُولِ إلى ذِكْرِ اللَّهِ يَسْتَشْعِرُ عَظْمَتَهُ وجَلالَتَهُ، وعِنْدَ الوُصُولِ إلى الوَعْدِ والوَعِيدِ يَحْصُلُ الرَّجاءُ والخَوْفُ، وحِينَئِذٍ يَسْتَنِيرُ القَلْبُ بِنُورِ مَعْرِفَةِ اللَّهِ، والإسْراعُ في القِراءَةِ يَدُلُّ عَلى عَدَمِ الوُقُوفِ عَلى المَعانِي؛ لِأنَّ النَّفْسَ تَبْتَهِجُ بِذِكْرِ الأُمُورِ الإلَهِيَّةِ الرُّوحانِيَّةِ، ومَنِ ابْتَهَجَ بِشَيْءٍ أحَبَّ ذِكْرَهُ، ومَن أحَبَّ شَيْئًا لَمْ يَمُرَّ عَلَيْهِ بِسُرْعَةٍ، فَظَهَرَ أنَّ المَقْصُودَ مِنَ التَّرْتِيلِ إنَّما هو حُضُورُ
https://app.turath.io/book/26894
Keep supporting MuslimMatters for the sake of Allah
Alhamdulillah, we're at over 850 supporters. Help us get to 900 supporters this month. All it takes is a small gift from a reader like you to keep us going, for just $2 / month.
The Prophet (SAW) has taught us the best of deeds are those that done consistently, even if they are small. Click here to support MuslimMatters with a monthly donation of $2 per month. Set it and collect blessings from Allah (swt) for the khayr you're supporting without thinking about it.
-
#Culture1 month agoFar Away, Book 2: [Part 1] – Meilin’s Tale
-
#Culture6 days agoFar Away, Book 2: [Part2] – The Domain of the Dzungars
-
#Culture1 month agoFar Away [Part 31] – Following Your Lead
-
#Culture1 month agoA Case For Critical Reading As Muslims: Reading ‘The Power of Your Subconscious Mind’ Through An Islamic Lens
