Connect with us

Media

Muslims and Wikileaks: A Guide for the Perplexed

Published

Guest post by Dawud Israel originally posted here

“Who controls the past controls the future. Who controls the present controls the past.”
-George Orwell, 1984

Getting Acquainted with the Wikileaks literature:

Keep supporting MuslimMatters for the sake of Allah

Alhamdulillah, we're at over 850 supporters. Help us get to 900 supporters this month. All it takes is a small gift from a reader like you to keep us going, for just $2 / month.

The Prophet (SAW) has taught us the best of deeds are those that done consistently, even if they are small. Click here to support MuslimMatters with a monthly donation of $2 per month. Set it and collect blessings from Allah (swt) for the khayr you're supporting without thinking about it.

With all the furor about Wikileaks I thought it would be a good idea to start studying them. I’ve started compiling and saving some of the cable documents here at Ummah Leaks relating to Muslims and the Muslim world. My hope is that I’ll piece together a bigger picture, come up with some conclusions of my own, and who knows maybe even a plan of action…like some really amateur, hypothetical, imaginary-Caliphate intelligence agency! Haha!

For those of you who are a little behind, you can read the cable gate documents through any one of the mirror websites (the original website was taken down…along with a number of mirrors). And then you can run a search engine search using a google site search (site: website address/ “key term”) or browse through them using the name of the city that the cables would’ve originated from or by release date. Also worthwhile is the leaked Congressional Research Service (Congress’s think-tank) documents that were leaked back in 2009 easily found here. You can also follow The Guardian’s up-to-date coverage of the cables (but be a little skeptical of their one-line summaries). And to get a better idea about who Assange is you can read his personal blog or watch this documentary about Wikileaks. Just so you know, Assange was hacking and had a backdoor into US military security when he was 21, so it may be he knows a few secrets himself that he hasn’t released (I’ll hold off on making fun of his somewhat geeky persona).

It seems that with the revelation of Wikileaks, that the government is testing the waters; there is an opportunity for governments to see how people will react…and thus far, the reaction is telling. There is definitely talk but there is very little action in terms of real change- the purported goal of Wikileaks. That should lead us to ask: what to do with all this information? This is definitely not the same as finding out there was a Groupon coupon hidden away from you, but of finding out about how ugly our world has become and what ugliness is necessary to prevent it from becoming uglier. This intel can be used to try and hold governments to account, but how? The Wikileaks founders have taken the route of relying on journalists to get the word out and hopefully shake the US government up. Its easy to see how Wikileaks Cablegate wouldn’t ‘shtick’ and only make us more and more desensitized, and thus giving governments further license for dubious behavior. My contention is that these cables should be leaked, if anywhere, into a courtroom, where there is gravity to their content, besides mere gossip.

Naturally it has raised a flurry of questions about the utility of journalism, questions of government secrecy and trust, accountability and the ethics of transparency (to learn more about that visit Personal Democracy Forum). One can easily blame Obama’s allergic reaction to Cablegate as a sign of government shadiness, yet, it is quite a natural response since this is the first time something like this, or at least at this scale has ever happened. In the past there has been ‘targeted leaking’ in the case of the Iraq videos, where it is clear how the government should react- morally that is- but here its thousands of leaks, some secret, some sensitive, some banal…what does one make of them? From a Muslim view, we can pause and ignore the hypocrisy of certain puritan Muslim royalty, we can indulge for a moment and imagine how would the righteous Khalifs respond, and how they would deal with it? And it isn’t hard to imagine the scrupulous documentation of the Prophet’s life would carry over to scrupulous record of the righteous Caliphs lives and keep everything as open and as transparent as possible due to the fact that Allah is All-Seeing.

Israel behind Wikileaks?

Some Muslims, not knowing what to make of the Wikileaks and/or from probably not having read through them carefully, have started to claim that Wikileaks is in league with Israel, especially since the documents have come to support the American/Israeli agenda against Iran. I would attribute that not to the Wikileaks documents, but the media in how it distorts and conflates facts with suspicion and sensationalism. It would be good to read about how this has happened and what the Arab leaders REALLY think about Iran. Back to the point about Israel: Firstly, it would be too quick and too easy to conclude Israel is behind this or has a part to play in it, since there have been some damaging cables regarding Israel (see below). Secondly, Israel has always covered its tracks and been smarter than most governments in ensuring their security, it is clear that with the assets abroad that Israel has they can afford to look bad. Thirdly, Assange’s mention of Netanyahu is because they both support government transparency, although it’s clear Netanyahu supports it because he feels he can do as he pleases! And lastly, its not necessary Israel be behind Wikileaks from the start, but as long as an influence is exerted on the media, the final message the public receives can be twisted and distorted to their choosing. I contend that having Muslims dismiss the Wikileaks cables as a Zionist conspiracy is MORE beneficial to Israel’s interests–making Muslims look paranoid, clueless and out-of-the-loop and all the easier to manipulate and alienate from involvement and engagement.

Nonetheless, is there a possibility that Wikileaks is some sort of big psy-op (and some have already started alleging and implying it could be) especially due to a certain comment by Assange about 9/11? Of course, its possible, but maybe some part of us wants to believe that? In any case, we should keep it in the back of our minds as a running question. But let’s explore the possibility Wikileaks is a big psy-op. Let’s say Wikileaks is a psy-op, then it would be a good idea to keep Assange alive, and control the dissent- in other words, control the symbol of dissent. If, however, Assange was martyred– then big government would be instantly held as guilty of destroying democracy, and the masses would rush to hold the governments accountable– and widespread outrage would ensue. I wonder if this has occurred to others, but that is my own personal prediction. The other trajectory is that some Wikileaks people have defected and created their own project, called OpenLeaks and this suggest that Assange’s influence will decrease.

EDIT: Wikileaks has just recently stated they will release 3,700 Israel-related documents: “There 2,500 files related to Mossad and I have read only 1,000. So I don’t know about everything, I need more journalists including Arabs to read and analyze and put everything in the context for the benefit of the readers.” That should really scare Israel and I’m pretty sure Mossad will go after Assange!

A few surface observations on reading the Cablegate documents:

There are some things about Wikileaks documents that are inherently true, in that they do undeniably reveal some ugly things about how US imperialism operates and the “logic” behind it.  

-Intel sees people not as Muslim or Jewish, but as people- it sees right through people, spots their vulnerabilities, habits, reduce their personality to something that can be predicted, seek out how they can be manipulated, tricked, like shaytan would. Its clear any sign of backbone is seen as a threat and reason for further investigation and intelligence gathering- this is why Turkey’s Erdrogan is discussed thoroughly in the Cablegate documents.

-It’s easy to read the Cablegate naively and gullibly but its best to read in between the lines and with caution. If anything, what they do tell us is the standard of forethought, analysis and shrewdness that is needed in running a government, global super-power.

-Muslims as minorities: The USA is very concerned about Arabs/Muslims in France, where commitment to secularism has made few French to classify the North African immigrants as Muslims, but rather as simply immigrants. Related to that is a discussion about relations between the US and Muslims in Brazil, where the large population of Muslims is seen as a study group or experiment into how Islam will play out in other Western countries– the key term to watch out for here is MMC or Muslim Minority Country. This is telling because the US has been concerned for a while about the Muslim sympathizers in Latin America– Nicaraguan Sandinista have some relationship with the PLO, and recently Brazil and Argentina recognized Palestine as a country.

-It’s somewhat sickening to see that the politics of the Middle East can come down to something as trivial as the jealousy over the attention the USA awards to these Arab leaders. It’s also pitiful to read that Egypt’s Mubarak understands American Utilitarianism in dealing with the Palestnian “problem” is the only reason why he is in power.

The Vatican and the USA: The United States is ready to see the Vatican as a nation-state, but not a Khalifate? It’s also important to note that the Church behaves much like the USA, on a tit-for-tat basis, for example, not protesting against the Croat Nationalist Clergy in Bosnia because of their loyalty during the Cold War (remember the Prophet salallahu alayhi wasalam reprimanded Khalid bin al-Walid radiallahu anhu). If a Khilafa were alive today- in these geopolitical conditions- would it behave like the Vatican- whether forced by circumstances or not? It’s also interesting to note how the Pope’s policy’s are influenced by what culture he hails from (Italian, Latin American, Asian or African). Just some thoughts to reflect on while imagining a righteous Muslim government in today’s world…

-Vulnerable sites in the US war-fighting operation? Here, just so you get an idea as to how far the tentacles of US imperialism have to spread and what the all the cogs in the machine that are required to keep it functioning look like.

-Israel has blamed the EU for the weakening of Israeli-Turkish ties saying, if they had accepted Turkey into the European Union Turkey would not be looking towards the Muslim world. Its sad in a way that Turkey turned to the Muslim world only after being dejected, but no sooner did it discover its strategic worth and as a the bridge between 3 continents and knack for leadership in arbitrating between 2 major world civilizations.

-How many of you knew about the struggle of the Sahrawi people in Morroco and the Polisario?  See here and here to learn about this little known conflict.

-Wikileaks has also published some of the meeting notes of the infamous Bilderberg of conspiracy theorist lore viewable here and here. More Bilderberg Conference papers can be found here.

Indian and Pakistani politics over Kashmir. No surprise here.

-British Muslims? Worth reading this and this. This is bound to raise some discussion about the state of British Muslims.

-Canadian Muslims? Some revealing stuff from Canada’s CSIS about the harmlessness of Canadian Muslims and building relations with Iranian intelligence (surprised?)

-One of the suggestions made in some of the documents mentioned above is having American Muslim imams and artists fly to France and Brazil to help those countries integrate and manage their growing Muslim population is mentioned. Obviously, managing Muslim attitudes in ANY country is in the imperial interest of the US government, but I think it says something about agendas, that America’s control is not just over the Muslim world, but hegemony over Islam itself, and also that how things play out in the American Muslim community will have ramifications for all of the ummah.

There is plenty more that could be discussed and I’ll be continuing to read them, though it takes time, but I suggest doing your own careful reading. Its sad to see the place of Islam today.

More links:

How Arab governments tried to silence WikiLeaks

Closing question:

How would Malcolm X or MLK or Gandhi utilize the cablegate documents? Or would they utilize it at all?

Keep supporting MuslimMatters for the sake of Allah

Alhamdulillah, we're at over 850 supporters. Help us get to 900 supporters this month. All it takes is a small gift from a reader like you to keep us going, for just $2 / month.

The Prophet (SAW) has taught us the best of deeds are those that done consistently, even if they are small. Click here to support MuslimMatters with a monthly donation of $2 per month. Set it and collect blessings from Allah (swt) for the khayr you're supporting without thinking about it.

13 Comments

13 Comments

  1. Pingback: Muslims and Wikileaks: A Guide for the Perplexed | MuslimMatters.org « Yahyasheikho786's Blog

  2. Dream fellow

    December 25, 2010 at 6:16 PM

    Good research thought.

    Read cables at your own risk, of not getting any federal government job if you are intending to go into.

  3. Salman

    December 25, 2010 at 9:30 PM

    salaam aleikum,

    solid article, just missing a few other points which are extremely relevant to Muslims both in North America and abroad (as well as providing some context to violent actions by some misguided Muslims):

    1. a) U.S./UK Cooperated in rewriting Islamic curriculum for madrassas in Bangladesh:

    b) British government was training Bangladesh Rapid Action Battalion as a “death squad”:

    2. U.S. Twisted Ethiopia’s Arm to Forcibly Invade Somalia:

    3. U.S. Diplomats wanted India to Send Bollywood stars to Afghanistan to “fight terrorism”:

    4. U.S. Tour of Muslim community in Britain:

    Bollywood actors and executives agreed to work with the USG to promote anti-extremist messages through third party actors and were excited about the idea of possibly partnering with Hollywood as well.”

    and this one:

    U.S. Projects for Countering Extremism in UK:

    The Embassy proposes to bring the “Allah Made Me Funny” comedy troupe to the UK to participate in the Festival, building on the unparalleled success we achieved with their UK program last fall
    S/CT funds, should they be dedicated to the RAMADAN FESTIVAL UK would be allocated to cover travel costs (including airfare, lodging, M&IE, honorarium, and local transportation) for the Allah Made Me Funny group. The Embassy estimates cost for bringing the “Allah Made Me Funny” troupe to the UK to be 39,000 USD.

    Note: $39,000 for whitewashing U.S. colonialism, the Iraq war, Abu Gharaib, drone strikes, and U.S. backed dictatorships in the Muslim world. Allah (swt) did make some people not only unfunny, pretty shameless and degraded but pretty stupid as well. Most Arab puppets and Muslim traitors (i.e. Quilliam Foundation take in Millions more for the same “work”)

    All of these help to give insight into how the crumbling U.S. empire is still trying to manage the world. Best stated and summarized here (Wikileaks Holding U.S. Global Power to Account):

    “In reality, most of the leaked material is fairly low-level diplomatic gossip, which naturally reflects the US government’s view of the world, and crucially doesn’t include reports with the highest security classification…

    Much has been made of the appalling damage supposedly done to the delicate business of diplomacy. No doubt the back channels will survive the shock of daylight. But in any case the United States is the centre of a global empire, a state with a military presence in most countries which arrogates to itself the role of world leader and policeman.

    When genuine checks on how it exercises that entirely undemocratic power are so weak at home, let alone in the rest of the world it still dominates, it’s both inevitable and right that people everywhere will try to find ways to challenge and hold it to account.

    After the Russian revolution, the secret tsarist treaties with Britain and France were published to expose and challenge the colonial carve-ups of the day. In the 1970s, the publication of the Pentagon papers cut the ground from beneath the US case for the Vietnam war. Now technology is allowing such exposures on a far grander scale.

    Not surprisingly, US allies and client states come out badly from the leaks….It simply underlines the fact that after more than half a century the US still has to rely on laughably unrepresentative autocracies and dictatorships to shore up its domination of the Middle East and its resources. While Arab emirs and election-rigging presidents fear the influence of Iran and only wearily bring themselves to raise the Palestinians with their imperial sponsors, their people regard Israel and the US itself as the threats to their security…”

    —————————————–

    Let us hope and pray Muslims read these carefully and wake up to the world as it actually is, rather than the rhetoric politicians, govt. civil servants, and media talking heads try to convey it to be.

    • Zakariya Ali Sher

      January 2, 2011 at 5:06 PM

      Absolutely disgusting. The US has no God given “right” to control the world and treat everyone else as expendable puppets. No country does. And much of this seems to be driven by the same racist ideology that drove European competition with the Turks and Muslim Caliphates in previous centuries. In an era in which the United States is a multi-ethnic democracy with Christians, Muslims, Jews, Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists, Wiccans and pretty much every other group there can be no excuse for this.

      If anything, given our history and conflicts with Britain, Spain, Germany and Russia at various points in time, the United States should be looking at other countries as friends… potential partners, even equals. Who do we share the most in common with? Ex-colonial countries perhaps? But the dynamics of wealth and power are changing. Everyone talks about Brazil, India, China, Russia, South Africa and Mexico as the new world powers… but countries like Turkey, the Gulf States, Egypt, Iran, Pakistan, Indonesia and Nigeria are up there too.

      The world’s a changin’ and it isn’t the white Euro-American protestants who have the power now. Historically China, India and of course the Muslim countries were the most powerful and wealthy nations. Even in Europe it was the Mediterranean where civilization really began. So America would do well to accept this shift and work to bring other countries to comparable levels of wealth, development and freedom instead of sabotaging them as they have done with Iran and Saudi Arabia.

      As for the rest…

      Personally, I would much rather the US invest in entertainment than predator drones and propaganda. Art and music do far more to foster cross-cultural understanding, and instead of trying to appeal to Muslims – in the West or abroad – the US should also be worried about appealing to western non-Muslims. Instead of paying idiots like robert spencer and his ilk to spread their propaganda at schools and to law enforcment agencies, why not sponsor Arab (and Persian, Urdu, Wolof, Mande, Somali, Hausa, Panjabi, etc) music, cinema, comedy and the like. I know plenty of people who would appreciate that. I would appreciate it!

      You know, I’ll give you an example right here at home. Here in Chicago I frequently try and see Middle Eastern performers when they are in town. Over the last Summer the ‘war on terror’ ideology STILL prevented much of that. One performer, Munojot Yo’Ichiyevaa, classical Shashmaqam singer from Uzbekistan, was unable to get a visa to enter the country. Another performer, Natacha Atlas and her band, only got their visas at the last minute, and not all the musicians were able to enter the country. I’ve heard similar stories from other parts of the country. Why can’t Muslim musicians reliably get visas YEARS after 9-11?

      If the US really wants to win ‘hearts and minds’ then stop hassling innocent people. Better still, stop killing civilians in Pakistan, in Iraq, in Yemen and elsewhere. The money WASTED on mercenaries could be better spent on culture and learning.

  4. Pingback: WikiLeaks chief set to receive $1.5m. for autobiography – Jerusalem Post | Wikileaks Secret

  5. Pingback: WikiLeaks founder signs $1.5 mln autobiography deal – RIA Novosti | Wikileaks Secret

  6. Pingback: Muslims and Wikileaks: A Guide for the Perplexed | MuslimMatters.org | The Daily Conservative

  7. Pingback: Julian Assange signs $1.5 million book deal “to keep WikiLeaks afloat” – The Next Web | Wikileaks Secret

  8. Pingback: Assange Book Deal: WikiLeaks Founder Lands $1.5 Million Autobiography Deal – Huffington Post | Wikileaks Secret

  9. Shafkat

    December 27, 2010 at 8:56 AM

    As salaam alykum,

    JazakAllah for the article…

    Perhaps you would like to read what the American War Veterans (who have been ‘spot-on’ on many issues relating to American / Israel issues ) have to say about Wikileaks and the Israeli connection… It makes incredible reading ..

    http://www.veteranstoday.com/2010/12/25/gordon-duff-alternative-media-crushes-wikileaks/

    Ma asalaama

  10. Pingback: Fehmi Koru may be the first victim of Cablegate in Turkey. And another Wikileaks roundup | Erkan's Field Diary

  11. Dawud Israel

    December 30, 2010 at 12:10 PM

    Jazaka Allahu khayran for the comments and links.

    Shafkat: There is still a lot to come out still in terms of the Wikileaks- so time will tell…

    I’m personally surprised Muslims in Muslim governments haven’t leaked materials exposing the corruption in their ranks. Anybody can send anything- video, photograph, documents, to Wikileaks and they will popularize it.

  12. Zakariya Ali Sher

    January 2, 2011 at 4:51 PM

    Good article. Very interesting – and quite frankly disturbing – stuff there. It’s sad that the US government still thinks it has a divine right to control the development of other countries. And more often than not, it seems this involves keeping down our Muslim brothers around the world, perhaps an outgrowth of European competition with the Turks centuries ago.

    I am especially interested in seeing how this plays out between Latin America and the Islamic world. Unbeknown to many Euro-Americans, and even quite a few Arabs, there have been thriving Arab communities in Mexico and South America for centuries. Lots of Lebanese in Colombia for example (admittedly many of them being Christians), and I’ve seen claims that the biggest masjid in the Western Hemisphere is in Bogota. I’m glad to see Brazil recognizing Palestine. Perhaps this is the result of increasing South-South cooperation. After all, the world is not going to be dominated by white Euro-American Protestants forever. If anything Asia and the Muslim world have historically been far more wealthy and influential. Even Iberia and many of the former Spanish and Portuguese colonies inherited a legacy from the Moors!

    Speaking of which… I am proud to say that I know of the Sahraouis quite well. I wish that more publicity was given to them in the Arabic world though. Unlike Palestine, the Sahraouis are the victims of a fellow Arab regime. I remember having a discussion with an Egyptian friend of mine, who jokingly brushed it off by saying ‘Western Sahara had it’s chance.’ If you are going to stand in unity with Kosovo, or Palestine, or the Uighurs over in China, then at least recognize your fellow Arab and/or Muslim brothers in Sahara Occidental, you know?

    Just my two cents.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Trending