Connect with us

Quran and Sunnah

Common Mistakes When Dealing With Crisis in the Ummah


“What you see and hear depends a good deal on where you are standing; it also depends on what sort of person you are.”

-C. S. Lewis

Philosophers and writers have often discussed the importance of perspective and contemplation when it comes to understanding any issue; to not impulsively form an opinion without careful and thoughtful consideration.

Keep supporting MuslimMatters for the sake of Allah

Alhamdulillah, we're at over 850 supporters. Help us get to 900 supporters this month. All it takes is a small gift from a reader like you to keep us going, for just $2 / month.

The Prophet (SAW) has taught us the best of deeds are those that done consistently, even if they are small. Click here to support MuslimMatters with a monthly donation of $2 per month. Set it and collect blessings from Allah (swt) for the khayr you're supporting without thinking about it.

For us as Muslims though, while we can appreciate and find common ground in such quotes, we have something far more insightful and full of wisdom – the Qur’an. The recent crisis in Gaza has afforded the Muslim world a host of lessons and reminders elaborately addressed in the Qur’an, if only we would stop to consider them. Gathering from much of what I have been blessed to learn from different scholars of this noble deen, I have noticed some common mistakes widespread in the Ummah when it comes to facing crisis.

  1. Having a Negative Opinion about Other Muslims based mainly on News from Dubious Sources
  2. Generalizing regarding an entire population based on the actions a small minority.
  3. Mistaking success for defeat due to a lack of perspective on life.

The sad reality about every single one of these mistakes though, is that each one is addressed in the Qur’an and was faced at one point or another by the Prophet (saas) and his companions. In this article, we will try to analyze each of these mistakes in detail specifically as they relate to the current crisis in the Muslim world and then understand how we can correct our perception, insha’Allah.

Not to Trust the Corrupt Without Inspection

I recently read a very powerful and eye-opening article written by Johann Hari, a non-Muslim columnist for the London Independent, titled, You Are Being Lied to About Pirates (here). Of course, the general trend in all media outlets regarding the whole Somali pirate issue over the past several months is that these pirates are nothing more than lawless bandits with no regard for international law or civility. No one ever questioned the rise of these so-called pirates and what was the motive behind their brazen attacks. It was assumed that extreme poverty and the lawless atmosphere of Somalia had driven these “terrorists” to seafaring robbery for their own corrupt gains and nothing else. But educated people should realize that nothing in the human psyche is ever that simple.

What Mr. Hari astutely discovered in the course of his research was the hidden truth of a shocking crime of outrageous magnitude. To quote from his article,

In 1991, the government of Somalia – in the Horn of Africa – collapsed. Its nine million people have been teetering on starvation ever since – and many of the ugliest forces in the Western world have seen this as a great opportunity to steal the country’s food supply and dump our nuclear waste in their seas.

Yes: nuclear waste. As soon as the government was gone, mysterious European ships started appearing off the coast of Somalia, dumping vast barrels into the ocean. The coastal population began to sicken. At first they suffered strange rashes, nausea and malformed babies. Then, after the 2005 tsunami, hundreds of the dumped and leaking barrels washed up on shore. People began to suffer from radiation sickness, and more than 300 died. Ahmedou Ould-Abdallah, the UN envoy to Somalia, tells me: “Somebody is dumping nuclear material here. There is also lead, and heavy metals such as cadmium and mercury – you name it.” Much of it can be traced back to European hospitals and factories, who seem to be passing it on to the Italian mafia to “dispose” of cheaply. When I asked Ould-Abdallah what European governments were doing about it, he said with a sigh: “Nothing. There has been no clean-up, no compensation, and no prevention.”

At the same time, other European ships have been looting Somalia’s seas of their greatest resource: seafood. We have destroyed our own fish-stocks by over-exploitation – and now we have moved on to theirs. More than $300m worth of tuna, shrimp, lobster and other sea-life is being stolen every year by vast trawlers illegally sailing into Somalia’s unprotected seas. The local fishermen have suddenly lost their livelihoods, and they are starving. Mohammed Hussein, a fisherman in the town of Marka 100km south of Mogadishu, told Reuters: “If nothing is done, there soon won’t be much fish left in our coastal waters.”

Personally, after reading this I was furious that such a crime could be happening to our already weary brothers and sisters in Somalia! I mean how low can these people get – stealing the only livelihood from one of the poorest nations on Earth right now while dumping their toxic waste in the source of that very livelihood? But that feeling of exasperation was quickly followed by shame; shame that I had been so gullible to believe the whole story that was being sold to us by the European nuclear crime cartel responsible for this scandal. I never questioned what was happening, I never gave those poor people any benefit of the doubt and I bought whole-sale the lies and deception about them. I had forgotten Allah’s words wherein He said (what means):

O you who believe! If a corrupt person comes to you with any news, verify it, lest you harm people unintentionally, and afterwards become full of remorse for what you have done. [49:6]

I had made the same mistake that some of the noble Companions had made when they heard the ifk – the lie about ‘Aisha committing zina. I had assumed the worst about my fellow Muslim by not investigating the news brought to me by a corrupt source well-known for its brazen lying, deception and wanton distortion of the truth – the media.

So, in the face of the latest crisis in Gaza, I was careful to not make the same mistake. The media desperately wanted to sell an idea so that we would believe that Israel was justified in its aggression against the civilian population of Gaza. They wanted us to believe that these were not human beings, but a society – 1.5 million people in fact – of hateful terrorists. They wanted us to believe that Israel had tried so hard to make peace, had been so patient, since 2006 when the people of Gaza democratically elected their leadership. It was those evil people in Gaza who couldn’t abide by the treaties they signed. It was those terrorists to the South who were hell-bent on killing civilians with wanton disregard. They needed to be put in their place. Israel needed to show these people that they had voted for the wrong group and punish them for their “mistake”.

So, it was unfortunate to see a number of Muslims following this line of “opinion”. Had they looked a little deeper into reality, they would have discovered a number of disturbing facts. Firstly, even before officially being elected in 2006, Hamas had agreed to stop suicide bombings and had succeeded in doing so for a period of 18 months into late 2006. During that same period of time, Israel refused to ackowledge them as a political entity and continued a campaign of abductions and assasinations (here). June 2008 brought the latest cease-fire into play in which Hamas and Israel agreed to the following conditions: 1) Hamas was to stop rocket attacks on Israel, 2) Israel would open blockades of relief supplies into impoverished Gaza and 3) Israel would not attack territories in Gaza. Amazingly, Hamas didn’t fire a single rocket for much of the duration of this cease-fire, but it was Israel that continued to keep most of the routes into Gaza blocked in effect continuing its strangle-hold upon the Gazan civilian population and violated the cease-fire on, of all days the US presidential election day, November 4th. It was on that day that Israel entered into Gaza where they killed six Hamas “militants” as reported by the Associated Press (AP).

AP stories November 5th and 6th discussed the possible collapse of the cease-fire based on these attacks, but they went largely unpublished in the US where media attention was focused almost entirely on the historic presidential election. Moreover, a Nexis search found no reference to the raid in the transcripts of any television news broadcast during the period. It is nothing short of amazing how deceptive the media can be in such circumstances, especially when partnered with an equally deceptive news-maker. Wallahu musta’aan.

The solution to this disease of the heart is two-fold:

  1. Maintaining benefit of the doubt and generally a positive idea regarding your fellow Muslim
  2. Careful inspection into any matter in which they are accused which must include getting the perspective of the Muslim

Indeed, Allah has said what means:

The believers are nothing else than brothers. So make reconciliation between your brothers, and fear Allah, that you may receive mercy. [49:10]

And among the many beneficial hadith on this matter which must cause us to reflect upon the rights that our oppressed brothers and sisters around the world have upon us are the following:

Ibn Umar (ra) reports that he heard the Messenger of Allah (saas) say, The Muslim is the brother of the Muslim; he should not oppress him nor forsake him (when he is oppressed).” (Bukhari and Muslim)

Abu Huraira (ra) reported Allah’s Messenger (saas) as saying, “He who alleviates the suffering of a brother out of the sufferings of the world, Allah would alleviate his suffering from the sufferings of the Day of Judgment, and he who finds relief for one who is in difficulty, Allah would make things easy for him in the Hereafter, and he who conceals (the faults) of a Muslim, Allah would conceal his faults in the world and in the Hereafter. Allah is will support and help a servant so long as the servant supports and helps his brother ….” (Muslim)

So have we given our fellow Muslims in Gaza their rights? Have we been just to them by trying to understand their actions, by seeking the truth about what is really happening – or have we forsaken them and oppressed them by just accepting the “news” that is fed to us by a distorted media? How many a statement can we find right now from those claiming imaan wherein they seem so focused on the mistakes of their brethren that are microscopic when compared to the atrocities of their attackers? Have the people of Gaza committed sins? Yes they have – but then again, so have we all. Has their leadership possibly taken too much license in certain areas of Islamic law when it comes to the defense of thir own people? Yes they have, but when any other military force does the same thing, we have been far more forgiving of their excuses than we are for these people who are struggling to raise the banner of Islam and to promote the Sunnah in this blessed land.

So what then should our response be when we see some things from oppressed Muslim communities that appear to be contrary to the teachings of Islam? Let us again refer back to the hadith:

Narrated Anas (ra) that Allah’s Messenger (saas) said, “Help your brother, whether he is an oppressor or if he is an oppressed one.” People asked, “O Allah’s Messenger! We can understand how to help him if he is oppressed, but how should we help him if he is an oppressor?” The Prophet (saas) said, “By preventing him from oppressing others.” (Bukhari)

And the great scholar of hadith Abdullah ibnal-Mubaarak also says, “The believer is he who gives his brothers an excuse, and the hypocrite is he who seeks their slips.”

Does this mean that we should excuse them even in the face of indefensible actions? Absolutely not! Remember the justice with which Allah commands us in the Quran where he says what means,

O you who believe! Stand out firmly for AllAh and be just witnesses and let not the enmity and hatred of others make you act without justice. Be just: that is nearer to taqwa, and fear Allah. Verily, Allah is Well­-Acquainted with what you do. [5: 8]

So our understanding is that our position must be one of justice first, while at the same time seeking to find an excuse for the sincere Muslim who’s action may not be outwardly understood. If in fact no excuse can be found and it is clear that this Muslim has indeed transgressed the bounds set by Allah, should we then forsake him? No! What would you wish for yourself if you were in an impossibly difficult situation and your desperation led you to disobey Allah? No doubt, you would wish for His forgiveness. But are we asking Allah to forgive the trespasses of our brothers and sisters in Gaza? Are we asking Him to guide them and guide others through them? Are we asking that Allah cause their leaders to be just and upright? The last reminder I wish to give myself and the reader before moving on to the next point is to remember the beautiful statement of the Prophet (saas):

Abdullah ibnu ‘Amr ibnul-‘Aas (ra) reports that the Prophet (saas) said, “Those who have mercy will receive the mercy of the Most Merciful. Have mercy on those who are on earth, the One in the Heavens will have mercy on you.” (Tirmidhi ).

Generalizing About an Entire Population

As often as it happens to us as Muslims today, you would think that generalization would be the last mistake that we would ever make. But we have been slow to heed the warning of the Prophet (saas) wherein he said:

Abu Sa’id al-Khudri (ra) reported that Allah’s Messenger (saas) said, “You will indeed tread the same path as was trodden by those before you, inch by inch and step by step, so much so that if they were to enter into the hole of the lizard, you would follow them in this also“. We said: O’ Messenger of Allah, do you mean the Jews and Christians (by your words)” those before you”? He said: “Who else (than those two religious groups)?” (Bukhari and Muslim)

He (saas) warned us that we will indeed follow their behaviors, even ones that make no sense whatsoever (think of those Muslims who had “rat-tail” hairstyles, hang their pants so low that their underwear is on full display like “gangstas”, and other assorted absurdities) which is among the meanings of following them into a lizard’s hole. So it is no real surprise to see us following them also in the practice of generalizing about entire populations of people. How do we do this?

When was the last time the imam in your local masjid prayed against the Jews? Did the Prophet (saas) ever make du’a against an entire people like this? How often do we hear some Muslims generalizing about how Jews are this and that of one bad attribute or another? Can such accusations be found in the Quran and Sunnah? Let us briefly review some of the many ayaat just in surat Aali-‘Imraan in the Qur’an that deal with the People of the Book to see indeed how they are described by Allah, the Most Just. He says what means (emphasis is mine):

A party of the People of the Book (Jews and Christians) wish to lead you astray. But they shall not lead astray anyone except themselves, and they perceive not. [3:69]

Among the People of the Book (Jews and Christians) is he who, if entrusted with a great amount of wealth, will readily pay it back;and among themthere is he who, if entrusted with a single silver coin, will not repay it unless you constantly stand demanding, because they say: “There is no blame on us to betray and take the properties of the illiterates (Arabs).” But they tell a lie against Allâh while they know it. [3:75]

You [the generation of the Prophet (saas) and all who follow their way in general] are the best of peoples ever raised up for mankind; you enjoin all good and forbid all evil, and you believe in Allah. And had the People of the Book (Jews and Christians) believed, it would have been better for them; among them are some who have faith, but most of them are disobedient and rebellious against Allah’s Command. [3:110]

Not all of them are alike; a party of the People of the Book stand for the right, they recite the Verses of Allâh during the hours of the night, prostrating themselves in prayer. [3:113]

And there are, certainly, among the People of the Book (Jews and Christians), those who believe in Allah and in that which has been revealed to you, and in that which has been revealed to them, humbling themselves before Allah. They do not sell the Verses of Allah for a little price, for them is a reward with their Lord. Surely, Allah is Swift in account. [3:199]

But don’t be fooled into thinking that this pattern exists only in this noble and grand surah, for indeed it is found throughout the Qur’an:

Verily, those who disbelieve from among the People of the Book (Jews and Christians) and the pagans will abide forever in the Fire of Hell. They are the worst of creatures. [98:6]

Thus, Allah in His infinite Justice differentiates between those among the People of the Book who are righteous and trustworthy and those who are disbelievers and treacherous in their dealings. He does not generalize regarding them.

In the Sunnah of the Prophet we see this in practice where the Prophet (saas) would deal with some of the Jewish tribes harshly after their betrayals, but among others he was kind, generous and forgiving. How many a Jewish person accepted Islam simply due to the kindness and excellent character of the Prophet (saas), and how many a Jewish person even till today has accepted Islam for similar reasons. The behavior and attitude of a number of Muslims today is a sad departure from the Sunnah of our beloved Prophet and the righteous Companions who also displayed care and concern for the non-Muslims under their governorship.

We should be just in the realization that even in Israel there are those who are very distressed by what is happening not only now, but on a daily basis. There are entire organizations devoted to helping the Palestinian people live a better and safer life, people who stand at checkpoints and yell at their own soldiers for the mistreatment of Palestinians, people who bravely go on the record voicing their opposition of the discriminatory and oppressive practices of the Israeli occupation. These people have displayed one of the greatest acts in Islam, to speak the word of truth before an oppressive ruler and as such they are people who may very well be open to the message of Islam if they could see it in practice first.

The reason that the People of the Book have a distinguished status among the general category of disbelivers in the message of Islam is because they are the closest people to this belief. Our articles of faith are nearly identical and as such it doesn’t require much of a change for them to adopt Islam. For the Christian people, particularly in the West, we have been very accomodating in our dawaah, but ever since the Israeli occupation, our dawah to Jewish people has been lacking. It is wrong that due to the oppressive actions of a group of them that we deprive others of hearing the good of Islam and deprive ourselves of the natural cooperation in goodness that is allowed to us in Islam.

There is no doubt that Israeli policies are such that it is clear that they generalize against all Muslims. We are all equally bad in their myopic vision, but let us not stray from the Sunnah of our beloved Prophet by behaving the same way against them. This can only happen when we give every Jewish person that we meet the benefit of the doubt in regards to their character as did the Prophet. There is no contradiction between having caution when dealing with someone and also being open to the good that they might have. This is what the Prophet (saas) demonstrated and what the Companions acted upon. Another aspect of this justice is to specify in our du’a that Allah aid the believers against those People of the Book who have disbelieved and spread corruption on the Earth as opposed to making du’a against all of them, wallahu a’lam.

Beyond simply generalizing against the Jewish people in du’a, there is a far more dangerous habit that occurs not only among Muslims, but in all human societies – extremism. Shortly after the atrocities against the people of Gaza began, a Dutch of Arab lineage was arrested after he wounded two Israelis in a shopping mall in Holland with a hand-gun. Around the same time, a relatively unknown (I found a total of nine lectures by this Imam online whereas “popular” shuyookh have over 500) and elderly Imam in one of the Muslim countries issued a “fatwa” wherein he encouraged Muslims to attack Israelis and Israeli interests all over the world “in defense of Gaza”. Any rational person can see that these two individuals, amidst the hundreds of millions of Muslims world-wide, acted out of rage and unchecked emotion. Their actions are not representative of Islam or Muslims, but they represent a dangerous trend of the human personality which can be seen globally in different expressions (“road rage” killings, “crimes of passion”, “going postal” work place killings, etc.). Some people, be they Jewish, Christian, Muslim, Atheist or any other “ism”, do not control their anger and instead act upon it in terrifying ways.

The Islamic teaching on this matter is clear though as can first be demonstrated from the Qur’an:

And race towards the way (which leads to) forgiveness from your Lord, and for a Paradise as wide as are the heavens and the earth, prepared for the pious. Those who spend (for the sake of Allah) in prosperity and in adversity, who repress anger, and who pardon men; verily, Allah loves those who excel in doing good. [3:133-134]

Ibn Kathir states in regard to the latter portion of these ayaat,

“for when they are angry, they control their anger and do act upon it. Rather, they even forgive those who hurt them. Imam Ahmad recorded that Abu Hurayrah (ra) said that the Prophet said, “The strong person is not he who is able to physically dominate people. The strong person is he who overcomes his rage when he is angry.” [Also Bukhari]

Also from guidance of the Prophet (saas) is the following hadith:

Abu Hurairah (ra) reports that a man said to the Prophet (saas), “Advise me.” “The Prophet (saas) said, “Avoid rage (sometimes translated as “Don’t get angry“)” The man asked (the same question) again and again, and the Prophet said in each case, “Avoid rage.” (Bukhari)

Furthermore, when it comes to doing any deed for the sake of Allah we must remember that our sole motivation must be only the pleasure of Allah and in accordance with His limits. Emotion must always be removed from the equation lest it over-ride our primary intention of pleasing Allah and submiting to Him. An example of this concern and control is well illustrated in the story of when Ali ibn Abi Taalib (ra) was in a battle and was about to kill his opponent when the other man spat in his face. Immediately after this happened, Ali pulled away from him and walked away from him. The man, surprised, asked him why he didn’t kill him although he had the chance. Ali replied, “I have nothing personal against you. I was fighting you solely for the sake of Allah. If I had killed you after you spat on my face, then it would have become my personal revenge which I do not wish to take.” So as Muslims, we need to always remember that our actions are for the purpose of justice and good for mankind in submission to Allah and that we do not act on anger, revenge or any other emotion.

Mistaking Success for Defeat

This pervasive mistake in our Ummah today is most representative of our collective disregard for the Qur’an; Allah grants victory and we somehow see defeat. How so? One of the reasons is what I call “romantic comedy syndrome”.

The Romantic Comedy Syndrome is very typical in younger generations although with the general collapse in morality throughout the world today, it can be found in people in their 40’s and 50’s as well. The source of the problem is watching romantic comedy movies where the typical storyline is that of two star-struck “soul-mates” find their perfect match in one another in hopelessly romantic settings and events. I’m not saying that its completely impossible that a wealthy entepreneur couldn’t find his long lost soul-mate in a street prostitute with a “heart of gold”, but I don’t recommend that as a way of meeting promising marriage prospects for even non-Muslims. The end result is that we have this vaulted idea of love – or any other ideal – that is based entirely upon fantasy, which prevents us from having a normal relationship. For many young people seeking marriage, this leads them on a mythical quest for “the one” which most often results in finally “settling” for a distant second choice in their late twenties or early thirties because their “perfect” match was never found. For others, they are so deep in their fantasy world that they believe they indeed have found “the one” or their “soul-mate” and when that magical romance dies 1-2 months into their marriage then they seek divorce or resolve to an unhappy marriage.

So how does this apply to crisis in the Muslim world? We have an unrealistic and vaulted idea about what victory means. For many people, victory would mean that the Gazans would overcome surmountable odds and defeat Israel whereby the Jewish people would be once again living under a Muslim rule. This of course would happen simultaneously with the return of the khilaafah and money falling from the heavens. The time expectation for these events would be next week at the latest. These ideas are clearly the result of complete ignorance of Qur’anic ayaat and historical precedent. To better understand how the help of Allah comes and why, let us return to the Qur’an first:

Those of you who turned back on the day the two hosts met (at Uhud), it was Satan who caused them to backslide (run away from the battlefield) because of some (sins) they had earned. But Allah, indeed, has forgiven them. Surely, Allah is Oft­-Forgiving, Most Forbearing.

O you who believe! Be not like those who disbelieve (hypocrites) and who say to their brethren when they travel through the earth or go out to fight: “If only they had stayed with us, they would not have died or been killed,” so that Allah may make it a cause of regret in their hearts. It is only Allah that gives life and causes death. And Allah is All­-Seer of what you do.

And if you are killed or die in the Way of Allah, forgiveness and mercy from Allah are far better than all that they amass (of worldly wealths, etc.).

And whether you die, or are killed, verily, unto Allah you shall be gathered.

And by the Mercy of Allah, you dealt with them gently. And had you been severe and harsh­hearted, they would have broken away from about you; so pass over (their faults), and ask (Allah’s) Forgiveness for them; and consult them in the affairs. And when you have taken a decision, put your trust in Allah, for certainly Allah loves those who put their trust in Him.

If Allah helps you, none can overcome you; and if He forsakes you, who is there after Him that can help you? And in Allah (Alone) let believers put their trust. [3:155-160]

Ibn Kathir explains these very important ayaat by reporting:

(Those of you who turned back on the day the two hosts met, Shaytan only caused them to err because of some of what they had earned) [3:155], because of some of their previous errors. Indeed, some of the Salaf said, “The reward of the good deed includes being directed to another good deed that follows it, while the retribution of sin includes committing another sin that follows it.” Allah then said, (but Allah, indeed, has forgiven them), their giving flight …

As for Allah’s statement, (And if you are killed or die in the way of Allah, forgiveness and mercy from Allah are far better than all that they amass.) [3:157], indicating that death and martyrdom in Allah’s cause are a means of earning Allah’s mercy, forgiveness and pleasure. This, indeed, is better than remaining in this life with its short lived delights. Furthermore, both the one who dies and the one who is killed will each return to Allah in any case, and He will reward him if he has done good deeds, or will punish him for his evil deeds …

Allah then addresses His Messenger and reminds him and the believers of the favor that He has made his heart and words soft for his Ummah, those who follow his command and refrain from what he prohibits. (And by the mercy of Allah, you dealt with them gently) means, “With Allah’s mercy you became this kind.” Al-Hasan Al-Basri said that this, indeed, is the description of the behavior that Allah sent Muhammad with …

(And had you been severe and harsh-hearted, they would have broken away from about you;) The severe person is he who utters harsh words, and, (harsh-hearted) is the person whose heart is hard. Had this been the Prophet’s behavior, “They would have scattered from around you. However, Allah gathered them and made you kind and soft with them, so that their hearts congregate around you.” `Abdullah bin `Amr said that he read the description of the Messenger of Allah in previous Books, “He is not severe, harsh, obscene in the marketplace or dealing evil for evil. Rather, he forgives and pardons” …

As for Allah’s statement, (Then when you have taken a decision, put your trust in Allah,) means, if you conduct the required consultation and you then make a decision, trust in Allah over your decision.

How do these ayaat relate to the current crisis some might ask? Let us take each ayah into closer consideration as it relates to our time.

The first ayah gives us a very clear understanding of one of the major obstacles to success and progress when Allah says what means (it was Satan who caused them to backslide because of some sins they had earned). Our adherence to Allah’s boundaries is a very real ingredient to success, and our disobedience of His commandments is a direct pathway to failure both in this life and the Hereafter. This matters very much today in our community globally because of the widespread lack of concern for obedience to Allah. I personally found it very shocking when I was recently in Egypt to be standing outside praying Isha’ on a reed mat extension of one of the smaller musallas as people walked by the rows chatting to one another as if nothing was the matter. They expressed absolutely no shame for not being among those who pray, and there were many who had no problem playing music loudly or shouting to their friends while the prayer was in session. This is unfortunately not limited to Egypt. In Ramadan, people may actually abstain from food and drink during the day, but they erase any good they may have attained from their action in the day by sinning all night in “Ramadan parties” where they eat and drink until about 1-2 hours before fajr and then go home to sleep until the mid-afternoon. Are they the people whom the Prophet (saas) described as getting nothing more from their fasting than thirst and hunger? Yes, there is to a degree some “awakening” among our youth, but there is an entire other subset of youth who are ten times more astray and more sinful than the last generation. All of this contributes to our collective failure as an Ummah in so many endeavors.

The second ayah describes another scene ripped directly from many bloglines and comments today, where Allah says what means (Be not like those who disbelieve [hypocrites] and who say to their brethren when they travel through the earth or go out to fight: “If only they had stayed with us, they would not have died or been killed,“). Today, there are a number of people who make statements like, “Had not Hamas launched rockets then these people would not have died. If only they would stop then these people’s lives would be saved!” These people have unknowingly made two great mistakes. Firstly, it is Allah who gives life and death and when Allah decrees for a soul to die then it shall die no matter where it is or what the circumstances are. The people who have died in Gaza have met their decree – were they not killed by Israel, they would have died another way. Secondly, it should be very clear to those who closely analyze the news reports that the recent actions of Hamas have little bearing on today’s situation. It has been confirmed in numerous news reports that Israel had been planning this ground invasion into Gaza for close to six months now. Certainly, it feels that it has more of an “excuse” now, but had things been different there is little doubt that another reason would have been manufactured. Why?

The current invasion and relentless bombing campaign have the removal of Hamas as their ultimate goal. This has been stated in black and white terms. Why does Israel wish to remove this government democratically elected by the Palestinian people and replace it with another? It is simply because this government has not submitted to them like every other regional government. They have submitted to Allah and attempts to buy them off have failed. They have declared their loyalty to Islam and to the Sunnah and they have made great efforts to stick to this creed. This is of great concern to Israel because of its implications both to Israel and to the surrounding nations whose populations grow more and more fed up with dictatorships whose loyalty is to everything else but their own people’s interests. If Hamas can succeed then this may cause significant ripples in the pond of Middle East nations. For this reason, they must be demonized in every way possible. They must be dehumanized in the media until no one cares if they are killed or not. They must be stopped at all costs and this is what we see now.

The third ayah brings us to the issue of perspective, where Allah says what means (And if you are killed or die in the Way of Allah, forgiveness and mercy from Allah are far better than all that they amass of worldly wealth). There is a difference between what we see and what many of the people of Gaza see, a difference between our understanding and theirs. We see people dying needlessly in a horrifying attack that respects no standard of human decency or international law. They see people dying in the cause of Allah and attaining the greatest status with Allah.

The people of Gaza are a people, who in their own words, have chosen to stay in this land even though they know it will be difficult for them. They could leave, but they have chosen to raise their children in this land even though they know that they may lose them due to the aggression of the occupiers. They could leave, but they have stayed in this land remembering that it was this same land upon which thirty thousand of the Prophet’s companions were martyred in their quest for Jerusalem. To live in this land requires the heart of a lion and a will of iron. But life in this land also affords the ultimate status with Allah. It is ribaat – the guarding of the frontiers and its immense reward – and it is more. They have chosen to face the inhumanity of those who have mercilessly occupied them and slaughtered them so that they can be the standard bearers of Islam upon this blessed land. They stand strong in the face of their enemy shouting with their presence that you can take away our homes, our lands, our crops and even our lives but you can never take away our faith and the honor of maintaining the Islamic presence upon this hallowed ground. They want what is with Allah and they prove it daily with their lives.

The fifth ayah is also very descriptive of these noble people. Their leaders come from among them, and every time Israel kills or abducts them, they are replaced from the same pool of believers. They consult with their people by virtue of the fact that they are their people. And as a nation, they have made their decision to face Israel and have put their collective trust in Allah. They have been cut off from the whole world through the blockade placed on them. Their reliance upon Allah only increased when this happened as they realized that no one would help them except Allah. The governments of Egypt, Jordan and Saudi Arabia, for all their strength would do nothing – not even to open their borders to allow in much needed food or other humanitarian aid. No, it was Allah who allowed them to be cut off from the world so that thier trust and reliance upon Him would be pure and complete.

Through this they came to the ultimate realization, (If Allah helps you, none can overcome you; and if He forsakes you, who is there after Him that can help you? And in Allah (Alone) let believers put their trust.). They know the history of this embattled area and they know that it takes time for ultimate victory to come. The Prophet (saas) left Makkah after thirteen years of persecution and returned eight years later in victory. He was not victorious overnight even though he was the Messenger of Allah and even though he was aided by the very Angels. It took Saluhuddin twelve years to unite many of the Muslim lands (Egypt, Syria, Mesopotamia and Palestine), and tens of thousands of lives, before succeeding in overcoming the Crusaders to take back Jerusalem after it had been in their hands for 88 years. As such, Jerusalem will not return to Muslim governance in a few weeks or months. It will not happen without lives lost and without difficulties. The people of Palestine have understood this well – they understand that they may be blessed with either one of two victories; to take back Jerusalem or to die for the sake of Allah in the effort. To this end they have put their trust in Allah and their hope in His mercy, His help and His reward. In this there are a great many lessons for us to learn in our individual struggles and should cause us to increase our love for these noble people of Honor (‘Izzah). And Allah knows best.


Disclaimer:  As a citizen and resident of the United States, I am bound to respect the rules established by this government. At the time of this writing, the United States continues to maintain Hamas on their list of terrorist organizations despite the fact that they were democratically elected by their people in free elections. This thus prohibits any American citizen from knowingly providing material support or resources to Hamas, or any other organization listed.

The State Department website states: “The term “material support or resources” is defined in 18 U.S.C. § 2339A(b)(1) as “any property, tangible or intangible, or service, including currency or monetary instruments or financial securities, financial services, lodging, training, expert advice or assistance, safehouses, false documentation or identification, communications equipment, facilities, weapons, lethal substances, explosives, personnel (1 or more individuals who maybe or include oneself), and transportation, except medicine or religious materials.” 18 U.S.C. § 2339A(b)(2) provides that for these purposes “the term ‘training’ means instruction or teaching designed to impart a specific skill, as opposed to general knowledge.” 18 U.S.C. § 2339A(b)(3) further provides that for these purposes the term ‘expert advice or assistance’ means advice or assistance derived from scientific, technical or other specialized knowledge.” To further explore this matter please see the State Department website here.

Thus, I wish to clarify that the purpose of this article has been specifically aimed at religious education and that although Hamas has been mentioned, at no point in time (presently or in the past) have I encouraged or recommended any material support or resources to be directed to them until such time as they are removed from this list. I believe that adherence to the law of the land is a confirmed part of Islam and as such I have made all efforts to make this clear in my writing and speaking. Their mention in this article or elsewhere in my writings has been solely for educational purposes.


Keep supporting MuslimMatters for the sake of Allah

Alhamdulillah, we're at over 850 supporters. Help us get to 900 supporters this month. All it takes is a small gift from a reader like you to keep us going, for just $2 / month.

The Prophet (SAW) has taught us the best of deeds are those that done consistently, even if they are small. Click here to support MuslimMatters with a monthly donation of $2 per month. Set it and collect blessings from Allah (swt) for the khayr you're supporting without thinking about it.

Dr. Ali Shehata is the author of Demystifying Islam: Your Guide to the Most Misunderstood Religion of the 21st Century. Dr. Ali is an Emergency and Family Medicine physician currently living in an area of central Florida. He was born in Maryland to parents who had immigrated to the US from Egypt. He has studied Islam mainly through traditional methods among various scholars, du'at and students of knowledge here in the US.



  1. Serendipitouslife

    January 12, 2009 at 7:33 AM

    JazakAllahkhair bro Shehata for this very enlightening article/advice.

    The Quranic evidences, that support non-generalization of people & nations, were a real eye-opener.

    You are correct about our viewing perspective. If that can be changed, we might just end up envying the Gazans for the honorable position Allah Subhanawataala has placed them in, & the unimaginable rewards they stand to gain inshaAllah.

    JazakAllahkhair for pointing to our mistakes & correcting them.

  2. Ibn Jafaar

    January 12, 2009 at 8:31 AM

    oh man! wonderfull

    so in summary, not ALL Jews in Palestine, even though they are ALL occupiers, are bad?!

    and we have to obey the law when it says not to support the mujahideen?!

    So let me ask you, can we make dua, or is that illegal too? I mean it is an intangible religious service right?

    To hell with your american law……

    What a joke this is….

  3. Amad

    January 12, 2009 at 10:06 AM

    Ibn Jafaar, I bet you didn’t even read the entire post. And I would be surprised if you did, based on your callous comment. If you cannot respect people of knowledge, even if you have a legitimate disagreement, then please refrain from making comments.

  4. Ibn Jafaar

    January 12, 2009 at 10:13 AM

    The line about israelis and the disgusting disclaimer ruined the whole thing

    Mostly the disgusting disclaimer

  5. SoS

    January 12, 2009 at 10:30 AM

    Wow Br. Ibn Jafaar, do you really think every single Jew in Palestine is for the occupation? Have you never heard of the Jews who’ve been JAILED for refusing to join the Israeli Army because they believe the occupation is unjust? Go google “Shministim” but here’s an excerpt of their letter ”

    We oppose the actions taken in the name of the “defense” of the Israeli society (Checkpoints, targeted killing, apartheid roads-available for Jews only, curfews etc.) that serve the occupation and exploitation policy , annex more conquered territories to the State of Israel and tramples the rights of the Palestinian population in an aggressive manner. These actions serve as a band-aid covering a bleeding wound, and as a limited and temporary solution that will accelerate and aggravate the conflict further.

    We expostulate the plundering and the theft of territories and source of income to the Palestinians in exchange to the expansion of the settlements, reasoning to defend Israeli territories. In addition, we oppose any transformation of Palestinian cities and villages to ghettos without minimal living conditions or income sources enclosed by the separation wall.

    We also protest the humiliating and disrespectful behavior of the military forces towards Palestinians in the West Bank; violence towards demonstrators, public humiliations, arrests, destruction of property regardless to any safety or defense needs, all of which violate global human rights and international law.

    We hereby challenge every citizen who wonders if the military’s policy in the occupied territories is conducive to the progression of the peace process, to discover by himself/ herself the truth and to lift the veil which distorts the reality of the situation; to verify statistical data; to look for the humane side in him/her and in the society which stands in front of him/her, to disprove the myths that were routed within us regarding the necessity of the IDF’s in the Palestinian Occupied Territories, and to stand up against every action which he finds irrational and illegal.


    Or the 1000 Israelis who protested in Tel Aviv against the attacks on Gaza?

    Or what about the Jewish Voice for Peace, who’ve condemned the attacks, urged the US Senate to vote NO on the Israel Resolution, and for that matter, strongly condemned the Obsession DVD’s of last year’s campaign?

  6. SoS

    January 12, 2009 at 10:31 AM

    They’re all just Yahoodee tricks to divide Muslims, right? Damn, why didn’t I see that?

  7. Zia

    January 12, 2009 at 10:44 AM

    As sallamu Alykum,

    The meaning of some or all the verses which have been underlined (among/not all/party etc) has been misinterpreted. The author mentions after quoting those verses “Thus, Allah in His infinite Justice differentiates between those among the People of the Book who are righteous and trustworthy and those who are disbelievers and treacherous in their dealings. He does not generalize regarding them.”

    I think the author has misunderstood some or all of these verses.

    As far as I understand they refer and praise those amongst them who embraced Islam and become Muslim and Allah does not praise them for their worship in nights (to Jesus) and having faith in their false beliefs.


  8. mudsir

    January 12, 2009 at 10:57 AM

    Thanks for the article.

  9. Muhammad

    January 12, 2009 at 11:18 AM


    The ‘Disclaimer’ is a joke…..

    The Author should take a ‘Wala and Bara 101’ course with some student of knowledge and re-check his loyalty… Is he American first or a Muslim? If the law of the land one day is going to say that you can not give zakat, then is he is also going to stop giving zakat too?

    The Prophet (peace be upon him) said: “A human must not be obeyed if that involves disobedience to Allah. Indeed, obedience is only in righteous deeds” (Sahih Al-Bukhari with Fath Al-Bari, 13/121; Ahmad, 1/91; and the context is found in Al-Silsilah As-Sahihah, No. 181)

    I’ve hardly visited this site, and am quite disappointed…..

  10. Abu Noor Al-Irlandee

    January 12, 2009 at 11:56 AM

    Jazzak Allaahu Khayr for an article which makes many excellent points. May we all benefit from it inshAllaah.

    We must avoid falling into bigotry against all Jewish people. It is unjust and we should not let the injustice of some cause us to swerve from justice.

    This may not be the proper forum to address this issue, but I do believe that it is problematic that in a case where it would appear to be at least a collective obligation to aid and assist our brothers and sisters that we would do so only if given permission by unjust governments. This is true whether we are talking about western countries in which we live or “Muslim” governments.

    I believe it is imperative that scholars and community leaders amongst us address that problem in a serious way, in the meantime alhamdulillaah there are at least some ways in which we can help the masses of our brothers and sisters in Gaza and we should do so with all available resources inshAllaah. These include spreading news and understanding of what is actually going on and giving charitable contributions through agencies like Islamic Relief. If we are not doing those actions, then this shows that we would not do any action which required a greater sacrifice on our part even if we had the chance.

    And Allaah knows best.

  11. Ibn Jafaar

    January 12, 2009 at 12:27 PM

    We need to support our brothers and sisters, and the mujahideen. If anyone in America has the ability to support the mujahideen with money DO IT, but don’t tell ANYONE cause our community is full of snitchs who think it illegal to do so cause George Bush says so!

    We need to redefine our concept of legal and illegal…NOT giving material support to the mujahideen, when we have the ability to do so, is illegal.

    Pray for the victory of HAMAS, and the end of the Jewish State…

  12. Farhan

    January 12, 2009 at 1:31 PM

    Excellent article, ma sha Allah
    May Allah give strength to the Muslims and honor to Islam
    Allahumma salli ‘ala saydina Muhammad wa ‘ala Aali Muhammad

  13. Organica

    January 12, 2009 at 1:35 PM

    Thank you. Shall share.

  14. mudsir

    January 12, 2009 at 1:39 PM

    This is not the time to debate whether Hamas are mujahideen or not, though this is what the OTSI (occupied terrorist state of Israel) wants us to do. I think the disclaimer was required.

    Lets now concentrate on helping our brothers and sisters in Gaza by whatever means that we can. And this article has been in the right direction.

    Thanks again for taking the time to write such a thoughtful article, and overlook the comments of my brothers who are obviously angry at the situation and the injustice happening in Gaza.

  15. iman

    January 12, 2009 at 2:00 PM

    asalaamu alaikum,

    at least we should read with attention the good and try to understand what has enraged some of you.

    this person does not want to end up in guantanamo to be tortured and is making clear their position in case this article is brought up in a court of law. (disclaimer)

    Peace be upon the muslim ummah, and i would like to say to the author that these are hard times and the trials are unimaginable Allah is witness and i do appreciate your article. Happy to see that somene even bothers to go to this length to admonish us, and still has hope that we will even hear or understand.

  16. Gazacaust

    January 12, 2009 at 2:23 PM

    As Salaamu Aleykum,

    Know the hikmah (wisdom) behind the tests, calamities and afflictions for the believers. Like the Sahaaba learned from the mistakes of Battle of Uhad we should learn from the recent calamities as well.

    A true visionaries vision does not end at the wall in front of him, rather it surpasses all walls beyond his imagination.

  17. IbnAbbas

    January 12, 2009 at 3:43 PM

    Jazakallah Khair Dr. Ali Shehata, once again, for producing such a wonderful piece. Please ignore the over-zealous brothers who doesn’t look at the whole picture but are too quick in criticising a tiny portion in the article.

  18. Ibn Jafaar

    January 12, 2009 at 4:09 PM

    As if not putting that ridiculous disclaimer would land him in Gitmo! Come on guys!

  19. Ibn Jafaar

    January 12, 2009 at 4:12 PM

    So let me ask you, can we make dua, or is that illegal too? I mean it is an intangible religious service right? It is more powerfull then giving money right?
    So what if that stupid law said you can’t pray for “terrorists”, you saying you wouldn’t make dua?

  20. mudsir

    January 12, 2009 at 4:22 PM

    Well first of all Shaykh has put up the reason for the disclaimer and it is not gitmo. And we must pray for the people in Gaza and not for terrorists such as the OTSI (occupied terrorist state of Israel).

  21. Abu Amin

    January 12, 2009 at 4:31 PM

    It is sad that people have glossed over the excellent points made in this article and make a mountain out of the disclaimer. The reality is that one has to be cautious in these difficult times. It is a matter of fact for all those people in the West who claim that the West is the best place in the world to practice Islam in “its fullest sense” to see the real limitations. There are a number of people lingering in jails across the world who have been deprived of the greater good of caring for their families, raising their children and such because of mindless comments. This is where emotion overcomes wisdom. And this is one step in the overall process of limiting Islamic practice in such countries as has been done historically to Muslim minorities elsewhere. I personally can see the wisdom in that and how the author doesn’t want this or any other statement to ever be used to decrease his chances for good. No, the article will not land anyone in jail but it can be used by devious souls as additional evidence against someone as has been done in so many other mocked up trials in the past decade.

  22. Ibn Jafaar

    January 12, 2009 at 4:48 PM

    being cautious is different than being afraid of your own shadow.and the article for the most part was good, the parts i highlighted, like the disclaimer and the line about some Israelis being good messed it all up…

  23. Ibn Jafaar

    January 12, 2009 at 5:01 PM

    Look, I guess I should make myself clear before Ali responds… so this is directed to Ali….

    Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh

    Bro, first off I wanna say I like (most) of what you have to say, in the above and in other places. I read your short bio on here and honestly I am impressed. You seem like a very good and active brother, who has and will do, I’m sure, more for Islam and Muslims than me or many who might critize you. I didn’t realize you also wrote a couple books….one looks like it is ment for non-muslims, the other I would like to buy. It looks wonderfull. I want to stress the point that I respect and look up to up…you seem like a great guy.

    That being said I stand by my criticism regarding what you said about “good” Israelis and the disclamier. They were both really uncalled for.

  24. Ali

    January 12, 2009 at 5:06 PM

    To Ibn Jaffar,

    Instead of “wasting” your valuable time here on the “blog” why don’t you give your “valuable time and efforts” to your brothers who need the most in Gaza. Physically, spiritually, emotionally and financially. Go…GO.. Ibn Jaffar Mujahid

  25. Ali Shehata

    January 12, 2009 at 6:32 PM

    Salaam alaikum wa rahmatallah wa barakaatuhu,

    Brother Ibn Jaafar, I would like to thank you for the good things you said and for taking the time to read the article, walhamdulillah.

    You have said that my article claims there are good Israelis and so I would like you to look through the article again before you misquote. As far as the disclaimer, if you feel it is uncalled for then alhamdulillah that is your opinion and we are allowed to differ in our approach. I on the other hand felt it is necessary. There was once a well respected scholar named Dr. Ali Tamimi who was in Virginia. He used to give classes and I believe you can find some of his articles and lectures online. Unfortunately, some people took some of his teachings overboard and allegedly used them as a basis for launching some attacks within America. He is now serving life in prison where his dawaah is limited, his ability to benefit the Muslim community here is practically zero and he is cut off from his family. If this was another time and place and he had fought for the sake of Allah and opposed an oppressive ruler who then jailed him for that, then maybe that would be different. But he is unable to do a lot of good because someone mistook his words and allegedly used them as a basis for a poorly thought-out act of extremism. As Muslims we try to take lesson from what happens to others.

    If you cannot understand this, then you should again try your best to be respectful of someone you think is in a higher position of knowledge than you and with more experience. My reasons for doing so may not need to be clear to you and in the end may not be necessary at all, but we live in difficult and insecure times especially for du’aat. Accepting some limitations if they are a lesser evil is something the Prophet indeed did in the treaty of Hudaibiyyah. The Companions did not like the terms of the treaty at all, but they never disrespected him nor spoke against him. That treaty, even with its clear aspects of submissiveness at times to the pagans of Makkah, was called a “clear victory” by Allah in surat al-Fath. It resulted in thousands of people accepting Islam and eventually in the peaceful conquest of Makkah. This is my hujjah for temporarily accepting such a condition – temporary because this law may change. Since there is a precedent at this time for jailing people and other forms of injustice (rendition, etc.) because someone may misinterpret your message and use it as a basis for criminal acts, I felt it was necessary and a necessary thought that should cross the mind of all du’aat.

    This would also be my response to brother Muhammad who would like me to review al-Walaa’ wa-Baraa’. Remember ya akhi, that even hating something in your heart is still part of imaan, and it is part of hikmah if it results in a greater good.

    As for the comments about Jews that other people have an issue with, I certainly expected some flak for the points I made. Zia, the ayaat are clear and yes they do include – among others – those who have accepted Islam. What about those who have not yet learned about Islam, but Allah knows they will accept it in the future when they do get introduced to it? Are the evil and wicked and worthy of death until they get this knowledge? Certainly you cannot say so!

    Everyday alhamdulillah someone accepts Islam in many countries around the world – some of these people come from Jewish backgrounds and they fall under the description Allah gives in the Qur’an which is explained under the following heading in Ibn Kathir:

    The BELIEVERS among the People of the Book

    Allah tells us that the pious scholars among the People of the Book believe in the Qur’an, as He says:

    (Those to whom We gave the Book recite it as it should be recited, they are the ones who believe therein) (2:121).


    (And there are, certainly, among the People of the Scripture, those who believe in Allah and in that which has been revealed to you, and in that which has been revealed to them, humbling themselves before Allah) (3:199).


    (Verily, those who were given knowledge before it, when it is recited to them, fall down on their faces in humble prostration. And they say: “Glory be to our Lord! Truly, the promise of our Lord must be fulfilled.”) (17:107-108)


    (Those to whom We gave the Scripture before it, they believe in it. And when it is recited to them, they say: “We believe in it. Verily, it is the truth from our Lord. Indeed even before it we have been from Muslims.”) meaning, `even befor e the Qur’an came we were Muslims, i.e., we believed in One God and were sincerely responding to Allah’s commands. These will be given their reward twice over, because they are patient,) [28:52-54]

    means, those who have this characteristic — that they believed in the first Book and then in the second. Allah says:

    (because they are patient,) meaning, in their adherence to the truth, for taking such thing upon oneself is not easy for people. It was reported in the Sahih from the Hadith of `Amir Ash-Sha`bi from Abu Burdah that Abu Musa Al-Ash`ari (ra) said that the Messenger of Allah (saas) said:

    (There are three who will be given their reward twice: a man among the People of the Book who believed in his Prophet then believed in me …)

    Imam Ahmad recorded that Abu Umamah said: “On the day of the Conquest [of Makkah] I was walking alongside the Messenger of Allah as he was riding, and he said some very beautiful words, including the following:

    (Whoever among the people of the two Books becomes Muslim, he will have his reward twice, and he has the same rights and duties as we do. Whoever among the idolators becomes Muslim will have one reward, and he has the same rights and duties as we do.)”

    So, Allah describes these people as believers and as having righteousness before they accepted Islam because they had not been properly introduced to it until that time. Certainly a person from among them who hears about Islam and then rejects it out of pride or such then he can never be called righteous or a believer, and to say so would be entirely against our aqeedah.

    So, I hope that this explanation will cool the hearts to some degree and help us get back to the points being made in the article. As people of Justice, we need to be just and recognize that there are people even within Israel who are not there as occupiers but taking the opportunity to oppose the occupation and the oppression that comes with it towards the people of Palestine. In some ways, they are like the Companion Na‘eem ibnu Mas‘ood who accepted Islam during the Battle of the Trench but was commanded by the Prophet to remain among the ahzaab to sow dissention. These people are doing something good even if they never accept Islam and it was the sunnah of the Prophet (saas) to ackowledge the good no matter from whom it came. He recognized the inherent justness in Mut’am ibnu Jubayr as an example. Our recognition of thier good is a significant point in our dawaah to such people – we should recognize that they have much in common with us as people who believed in Musa (as) and have continued to stand even against the actions of thier own people for justice. If I could be there, then these would be people I would very much like to invite to Islam and I would be hopeful that Allah would open their hearts to it.

    Furthermore, Israel is not the only place in the world with a Jewish population. To make general du’a against “Jews” is to include other people who have nothing to do with the atrocities of the Israeli state. Again, this detracts from our message of dawaah to a people of the Book. This shows us as emotional, angry people who cannot differentiate between one and another. If we are unable to do that, I do not think we should be so unahppy when America or Europe lumps all Muslims together with the extremists. The guidance of Islam requires better of us than such a shallow mentality and I ask Allah to guide my heart and the hearts of all Muslims to that which is in line with the manners of this noble deen and to not make us among those who oppress with our opinion, our words or our actions – ameen.

  26. Ali Shehata

    January 12, 2009 at 6:52 PM

    Salaam alaikum everyone,

    I would like to also remind – especially my younger brothers and sisters – of one important manner when it comes to disagreement. I know that when it comes to knowledge that I am a nobody, and I do not claim to have any status or any position. I am a regular Muslim at best, humbled and sometimes blinded by my own baggage of sins. Sometimes I too hear a statement from one of my teachers who are far above me in honor, righteousness, knowledge and all good – yet I may disagree with them. My initial approach to such a disagreement is not to disparage them or to put them down or to call them names. To do so would mean that I think i am better than them and that I am hence looking DOWN upon them; a description which the Prophet (saas) said would keep a person out of Jannah (at least temporarily) as in Sahih Muslim.

    If one of you looks down upon me, then I would say that I would be deserving of it because I know myself and I know how low I am because of my weakness in this deen. But it is a dangerous trend that I hope you do not repeat with others – scholars, du’aat or just an average Muslim who attends your masjid or halaqah.

    The approach that may be the most compatible with the humility we all should have before Allah is to think the best of your brother, to give them the benefit of the doubt (which ironically is the first point in this article that seems to have been missed by some). Assume that they are better than you and wiser and that YOU have missed something – then ask them how they came to that conclusion. I know that some people may be shocked to read this, but you may actually LEARN something when you approach disagreement this way. For knowledge cannot fully enter the heart that possesses arrogance, pride or contempt for another Muslim.

    I am sure that there are many people who comment on my posts who are greater in knowledge than me, and I aspire to reach that level and beyond. But more important than decorating myself with knowledge that has no accompanying action, I prefer to have the manners of student of knowledge first so that when I do come into contact with the knowledge that I will know what properly to do with it, wallahu ‘ala wa a’lam.

  27. Ibn Jafaar

    January 12, 2009 at 7:10 PM

    Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh Ali…

    Well once again I am impressed with your calm, mature, and patient reply. I am being very honest when I say I have a high level of respect for you, and this respect only increases when I see your calm and detailed reply to those that disagree with you (even in a rude way). That being said I still stand by what I said…but I said it all so there is no need to disagree further. But just remeber that in times like these emotions run high…it is only natural

    That being said I agree with the majority of what you say (here and else where) anyway…

    Thank you for your service to Islam and Muslims….keep it up bro.

  28. Ibn Jafaar

    January 12, 2009 at 7:18 PM

    BTW, I took a look at your book and it looks great. InshaAllah more are on the way…

    Us english speaking Muslims need more books written in english, and not translated.

    Really bro…keep up the good work..

  29. Algebra

    January 12, 2009 at 7:24 PM

    Would you write something on MANNERS……….. i mean really i just don’t understand why so many people born and raised in the states call their Mothers “Wus UP’ and elders bros……………..
    I mean i am born and raised here and our parents advised us of how to talk to teachers, counselors, and parents with respect………..
    I don’t get this attitude……………

    sometiemes there remarks can be a turn off………….. i mean really we are suppose to have the highest regard for our parents especially our MOTHERS………..
    we are suppose to call elders “AP” and talk with IHTARAM and respect…………..
    uh anyway its a turn off.
    i does one put that in a nice way………. for someone to understand………… I mean if a DA’EE like some people i know talks like “wus up’ i am just not going to be motivated in listening to him.

  30. Ibn Jafaar

    January 12, 2009 at 7:31 PM

    Since I got your attention……what was the reason/context for the oft quoted ayah in surah Ar-Ra’d?

    This isn’t like a test question…I really wanna know…

  31. Nur el Masih Ben Haq

    January 12, 2009 at 8:23 PM

    WAR ON GAZA: Let us React Like Godly People
    I am baffled by the responses of some people, who call themselves Christians, to the massacre taking place in Gaza. On the other hand, I am impressed by the attitude of those who demonstrate the true Christian spirit by calling for prayers and immediate end to the disproportionate war.
    It is true that the foolish and terrorist leadership of the Hamas instigated the war by firing rockets severally on Israeli civilians. But that is not an excuse for Israel to massacre numerous innocent civilians in Gaza. They should confine their understandable vengiance to the real culprit, the notorious leadership of the Hamas; but not extend it to numerous innocent civilians at all.
    Don’t misunderstand me, as a Christian and an advocate of justice, not only do I endorse Israel’s right to exist, but would go out of my way to even expose any plans against the State of Israel just as I would do in respect of an Arab country. But no honest person would be indifferent to the way Israel is capitalizing on the foolishness and foolhardiness of the leadership of Hamas to massacre their Arab cousins. The massacre in Gaza is extremely Godless. God loves the Gazans the same way He loves the Israelis because He is the creator of both brothers. And God hates killing of non-Christian civilians too. It is therefore very immoral for any true Christian to be indifferent or even support a situation where Israel keeps excessively pounding Gaza in the name of retaliating the Hamas rockets that hardly kill a fly in Israel.
    Christian Arabs all over the World are praying for the civilian Gazans and of course, Israeli civilians.
    But it must be admitted that to whom more is given, more is expected. Therefore, since God has given Israel more high precision military powers than the Hamas, they (Israelis) are morally supposed to use their high precision military technology to exclusively strike at the Hamas leaders and not the innocent civilians. On the other hands, it would be unrealistic to expect the Hamas to exclusively strike at Israeli soldiers because they don’t have the high precision military technology. They just manage to fire un-guided rockets for ego boosting. That is even the reason why in the 18th day of the war Hamas has been able to kill just 13 Israeli citizens, one of which is an Arab as against Israeli soldiers that killed over 919 Gazans, many of which are innocent civilians. Many of those killed by Israelis might not have actually been supporting Hamas while alife.
    So, we should all blame the Hamas for ending the cease fire especially when it knew it did not have the military capacity to face Israelis or defend the innocent civilian Gazans. But Israel should be blame more for excessive retaliation against even a weaker opponent. In any case, this disproportionate war must end.

  32. Ali Shehata

    January 12, 2009 at 9:03 PM

    Salaam alaikum Dear Brother Ibn Jaafar

    May Allah reward you for your manners even in disagreement, wa lilaahi alhamd.

    I think you are referring to the ayah, “Allah does not change the condition of a people until they change what is in their hearts.” If not please clarify.

    The idea is mentioned in a slightly different wording first in surat al-Anfaal:

    That is so because Allah will never change a grace which He has bestowed on a people until they change what is in themselves. And verily, Allah is All-Hearer, All-Knower. Similar to the behavior of the people of Fir`awn, and those before them. They belied the Ayat of their Lord, so We destroyed them for their sins, and We drowned the people of Fir`awn for they were all wrongdoers. [8:52-53]

    Ibn Kathir states: Allah affirms His perfect justice and fairness in His decisions, for He decided that He will not change a bounty that He has granted someone, except on account of an evil that they committed.

    The original context in al-Anfaal was Badr. As far as the reason behind the revelation in ar-Ra’ad I do not know that there is a specific one. The way it is represented in the Qur’an is that Allah will not change the good condition – the blessings and ease – that He has bestowed upon a people until they change what is in their hearts (by disobedience, kufr, ingratitude towards His blessings by not using them for halaal, etc.). It also applies in reverse, that Allah will not change the bad condition that a people are in until they change what is in their hearts. This has been the reason behind the emphasis on our good deeds these days because our condition as an Ummah can never change until we collectively go back to Allah by obeying Him in at least the obligatory matters, wallahu a’lam.

  33. Ali Shehata

    January 12, 2009 at 9:08 PM

    Nur el Masih,

    Thank you for your comment but Hamas did not end the cease fire as has been detailed in several places both on this blog and in the media at large. Israel violated the cease fire by killing 6 Gazans on Nov. 4th and had been violating the cease-fire condition of opening the blockade of humanitarian aid supplies for the whole of the six month term. Hamas did not fire a single rocket into Israel until after the cease-fire ended even though Israel had not kept any of the terms it had committed to in July.

  34. Ibn Jafaar

    January 12, 2009 at 9:45 PM

    Thanks Ali…

    you know too often when people (muslims) disagree, we go to extremes. Like “fulan said XYZ which is wrong so he is my enemy and must be destroyed!” etc

    THIS attitude shows the ignorance we have of Wala and Bara…

  35. Abu Sabaya

    January 12, 2009 at 9:51 PM

    @ Ali Shehata:

    There was once a well respected scholar named Dr. Ali Tamimi who was in Virginia. He used to give classes and I believe you can find some of his articles and lectures online. Unfortunately, some people took some of his teachings overboard and allegedly used them as a basis for launching some attacks within America…But he is unable to do a lot of good because someone mistook his words and allegedly used them as a basis for a poorly thought-out act of extremism.

    When did this happen? This is news to me.

  36. iman

    January 13, 2009 at 12:59 AM

    asalaamu alaikum

    ibn jafar masha Allah, Allah is pleased with those who turn to him again and again in repentence.

  37. just to clarify

    January 13, 2009 at 1:00 AM

    assalamu alaikum

    Dr. Ali, I believe Dr. Ali al Timimi was actually imprisoned for allegedly inciting some youth to wage war in Afghanistan and DID NOT incite attacks within America. I know it is a small technicality, but better to be accurate with the facts

  38. ibnabeeomar

    January 13, 2009 at 2:42 AM

    this was a really good article, and made a lot of deep points. this one in particular stuck with me –

    some of the Salaf said, “The reward of the good deed includes being directed to another good deed that follows it, while the retribution of sin includes committing another sin that follows it.”

    jazakallahu khayr

  39. shireen

    January 13, 2009 at 2:51 PM

    as-salamu alaykum. JZK for the article.

    in one of your responses Dr. Ali you compared following the laws in this country to the peace treaty of the Prophet and the Mekkans. i do not see how a treaty that two parties come together to formulate is the same thing as obeying the laws of this country.

    i am not trying to say or imply that we should not follow laws (that is another big conversation) just questioning the comparison being made.

    ALSO. it seems that apart from a few muslims here or there, most are unaware and lack understanding of the real issues we are facing today. there are many many people writing articles about these issues, such as mentioned in this article, but muslims dont seem to be accessing these alternative venues of news.


  40. Nuruddeen Lewis

    January 13, 2009 at 4:40 PM

    Assalaamu alaykum,

    I would like to hear thoughts about the possibility of the Palestinians leaving their land. I know this has been proposed before and it caused a big uproar. I must admit that I don’t know everything about this situation, but my heart aches from what I do know of what is going on over there. Is it sensible for the Palestinians to give this land to the Jews and migrate to other countries? Why is such a solution so despised? Is such a migration even possible?

  41. Algebra

    January 13, 2009 at 4:58 PM

    I would like to hear thoughts about the possibility of the Jews to migrate to the States. I know when i bring this up it will cause an uproar but this situation is making me sad and after all it was initially the Palestinians land anyway………………. before world war 2.
    I just don’t understand why jews can’t migrate to america where there is an strong ziionist lobby anyway. WHY is my solution so despised i don’t understand please help me to understand DR. ALI SHEHATA……
    thank you
    please advise.

  42. Ali Shehata

    January 14, 2009 at 12:38 AM

    As-salaam alaikum Shireen,

    Alhamdulillah. Thank you for taking the time to read the post and comment. In regards to your question, my point in that comment was to say that as Muslims living under non-Muslim governments that we sometimes are put in the position to accept certain things which would otherwise being unacceptable in Islamic tradition. When we are in such a situation, we have two choices: a) to leave and find a more suitable Islamic environment where our practice is not constricted or b) to see if there is a good that we can accomplish in that place that otherwise would be difficult to accomplish if we lived elsewhere, and thus outweighs the evil we are facing. This is the principle of the lesser of two evils.

    The Prophet (saas) chose the lesser of two evils in al-Hudaiybiyyah and in our present circumstances we have a similar predicament. We play an important role today in the fabric of the United States and the US remains the country with the greatest percentage of Muslim conversions world-wide. Our presence here at this time plays an important role in balancing the views represented even in the media. There may come a day when such restrictions are placed upon us in our religious practice where the lesser of the two evils may be to live elsewhere. In the meantime, we have a lot of good work to do here in this society in the form of teaching people about the true nature of Islam, doing good community work and doing our best to use our position as citizens to effect positive changes in our government.

    To Brother Nuruddeen

    Salaam alaikum brother … I am curious to know if you are a convert or the child of a convert as your name would suggest. I can understand your confusion in this regards and I can see also why you might wonder why the Palestinians simply don’t move away to protect their lives. Since you don’t know the history it is understandable.

    The reason is because this is a land of Islam, and these people understand full well that their lives are in danger if they stay there, but also how much more dangerous it would be to leave it and surrender to the forces of oppression and genocide. This land has often been a land of strife but it is their home. They will not allow a land in which the third holiest site of Islam exists, a land in which Allah is praised and remembered and a land in which truth stands up to a manufactured lie as David stood before Goliath – they will never allow it to become a land where Allah and His Messenger are ridiculed, disparaged and attacked. They are not fighting for a flag, a country or a people – they are fighting to keep Islam from being extinguished in this land. This is the great honor which they have for which we should respect, admire and love them.

    I tried to think of a good example in American history but I could not, because the history of the israeli-palestinian conflict is a very unique one with few precedents in history. It is rare that a population of people comes to a foreign land as beleaugered guests (those who left Holocaust Europe to find peace and safe-haven in Palestine) only to rise up against those who offered them safe-haven and hospitality and murder them and take over their homes, properties and possessions because it was “promised to them in the Bible”. Maybe someone else can come up with a good example to help you better see what it is they are fighting for and why they will alhamdulillah never surrender.

    And Allah knows best.

  43. Pingback: Jewish Criticisms of Israeli Tactics - TalkRadio Interview |

  44. aamer khan

    January 14, 2009 at 7:51 AM

    Dr. Ali Shehata: an example could be the native americans. had they not saved the early colonists there would be no america, and look what happened to them…

  45. shireen

    January 14, 2009 at 9:37 AM

    i was just coming to say the same thing, the Natives. and in this case there was also the idea of the Bible supporting what the europeans did, i believe, they called it manifest destiny. plus the idea that the europeans were escaping religous persecution and serfdom to come to america the land of the free.

    i have often told muslims that muslims assimilating into american politics is not much different than if we were to go to the occupied lands and assimilate into israel.

    it is a shame that we are supposed to be a just community upholding Islam and yet we give no attention to what the american govt has done to the Natives and still continues to do to them. although they were almost wiped out, they have small pockets of communities and are the most poor in this country and still very oppressed. what tiny bits of land they have supposedly been given the american govt now uses either to mine for uranium or dump their garbage or something of the sort. although they are supposed to have autonomy, the govt will not allow them to do much. there is a documentary i have been wanting to see called standing nation about one family today trying to grow hemp and how the fbi burned down all their fields.

  46. Nuruddeen Lewis

    January 14, 2009 at 2:19 PM

    Wa alaykum salaam wa rahmatullah Ali. Alhamdulillah, I did convert to Islam about 6 years ago.

    I understand your point. However, the Palestinians are being extinguished and none of their Muslim neighbors (nearby countries) have officially agreed to help them militarily. And I pray to Allah that they are rewarded for their struggle. It may be in the best interest of the Palestinians and the Ummah as a whole to retreat and regroup. I think even our best examples of Muslim commanders would pull back under these circumstances. Certainly Allah knows best, but this, in my opinion right now, seems to be the most practical thing for the Muslims to do right now. May Allah grant victory to those he is pleased with.

  47. Hassan

    January 14, 2009 at 3:06 PM

    Nuruddeen Lewis said:

    Wa alaykum salaam wa rahmatullah Ali. Alhamdulillah, I did convert to Islam about 6 years ago.

    I understand your point. However, the Palestinians are being extinguished and none of their Muslim neighbors (nearby countries) have officially agreed to help them militarily. And I pray to Allah that they are rewarded for their struggle. It may be in the best interest of the Palestinians and the Ummah as a whole to retreat and regroup. I think even our best examples of Muslim commanders would pull back under these circumstances. Certainly Allah knows best, but this, in my opinion right now, seems to be the most practical thing for the Muslims to do right now. May Allah grant victory to those he is pleased with

    You know its not bad idea to retreat, regroup and retake. Just like in the crusades, we did loose jerusalem in between. But the problem is that “muslim” countries do not have balls to do anything. And they are always afraid of refugee/immigrants, as the monarchs feel threatened by their presence.

  48. shireen

    January 14, 2009 at 9:16 PM

    btw. JZK for clarifying my question above Dr. Ali.

  49. Sadaf Farooqi

    January 15, 2009 at 7:48 AM


    What an excellent article! May Allah reward the author abundantly. It has greatly added to my knowledge, particularly that of the historical aspect of the Israel-Palestine conflict.

    I think Dr Ali’s list of the common mistakes Muslims make during crises have been adequately proved true by reading – ironically – most of the comments under the article itself! Allah has demonstrated how right the author is in what he is saying about Muslims’ mistakes. I think our lack of knowledge is the biggest reason for these mistakes. Look at the way we talk to our learned da’ee’s and scholars; look at how we form opinions, pass judgments and make accusations, not to mention the biting sarcasm! Subhan Allah. We should be cautious and should hold our tongues before being emotional.

  50. captainjohann

    January 15, 2009 at 11:45 AM

    What is the solution to the misery of palestenians. Are they to endure? MUSLIM UMMA headed by Saudi arabia has blamed Hamas for the present crisis. the only Islamic nuclear power Pakistan is organsing demo and helping US to kill Iraninas through Jundoallha and infidel Indians through LET Ofcourse Zai ul haq of Pakistan killed 10,000 palestenians in 1973 in Jordan..Bnagladesh and Indonesia ,Malysia are just not bothered except to organise demo.
    Two state
    Unitary state
    Part of Jordan,egypt etc
    Merge with Israel
    what is the solution you offer.?

  51. Algebra

    January 15, 2009 at 1:45 PM

    @Sadaf Farooqi
    I concur with your INTELLIGIENT COMMENTS
    Thank you for sharing your assessment of the bloggers. you are very perceptive.

  52. muslimah

    January 15, 2009 at 2:25 PM

    i’msorry. i cant help it. they keep saying we teach our kids to kill. look at how sweet israelikids are.

  53. Gazacaust- Trials are blessing for a Muttaqi

    January 15, 2009 at 3:53 PM

    From the Greatest of Sins: Being Bored of Allah’s Blessings

    Ibn al-Qayyim said:

    “From the greatest of sins which are hidden – and widely practiced – is that the servant is enjoying a blessing that Allah has blessed him with and chosen for him, then that servant becomes bored of it and seeks to exchange it for what he thinks – due to his ignorance – is better for him than it, and His Lord continues to be merciful to him and does not prevent him from this blessing, and He excuses him due to his ignorance and this bad choice that he has chosen for himself. When he reaches the limit in scorning this blessing and his boredom with it overcomes him, Allah removes this blessing from him. So, if he is given what he sought in exchange for that blessing, and he sees the immense difference between what he was previously enjoying and and what he has now been given instead of it, his anxiety and regret increase and he requests a return to what he previously had. So, if Allah desires good and guidance for His servant, He allows him to bear witness that what he had was a blessing from the blessings of Allah upon him, and He causes him to become pleased with that blessing and to give thanks to Allah for it. If his soul then whispers to him to again seek to exchange that blessing for something else, he makes istikharah to His Lord, the istikharah of the one who is ignorant of what is in his best interests and unable to attain them. He turns his affairs to Allah, requesting of Him to help him make the best decision.

    And there is nothing more harmful to the servant than to become bored of the blessings of Allah, because he does not see it as a blessing, and he does not thank Allah for it, and does not become happy because of it. Rather, he belittles it, complains about it and considers it to be a disaster – all this while it can well be from the greatest of Allah’s blessings upon him.

    Most people have a feeling of enmity towards Allah’s blessings upon them, and they do not percieve that this opening that Allah has given them is actually a blessing, and they exert the utmost effort in repelling it and pushing it away out of ignorance and oppression. So, how many are those whom Allah’s blessings comes to one of them, and they rise to repel and fight against it? And how many are those whom the blessing comes to one of them and he strives to push it away and brush it to the side out of ignorance and oppression?

    Allah – the Exalted – says: {“And this is because Allah would not change a blessing that He has blessed a people with unless they change what is within themselves.”} [al-Anfal; 53]

    The one who is devoid of logic loses his chance * Until the affair passes him by. Then, he blames predestination.”

    [‘al-Fawa’id’; p. 248

  54. Fatimah

    January 15, 2009 at 4:19 PM

    Jazakum Allah khairun Br. Ali Shehata, Amazing reminders which I benefitted from tremendously. May Allah reward you immensely for your hard work.

  55. Gazacaust-Blessing of another Salahuddin

    January 16, 2009 at 1:56 AM

    From Salahuddin Ayyubi To the Muslim Ummah

    This is a letter written by Salah El Din A Ayyubi when he started his Jihad against the crusaders more than 9 centuries ago:

    “We hope in Allah most high, to whom be praise, who leads the hearts of Muslims to calm what torments them and ruins their prosperity.

    “Where is the sense of honor of Muslims? The pride of Believers? The Zeal of the Faithful?

    “We shall never cease to be amazed at how the disbelievers for their part have shown trusts, and it is the Muslims who have been lacking in zeal. Not one of them has responded to the call. Not one intervenes to straighten what is distorted; but observe how far the Franks have gone what unity they have achieved. What aims they pursue. What help they have given. What sums of money they have borrowed and spent. What wealth they have collected and distributed and divided amongst them. There is not a King left in their lands or islands, not a lord or a rich man who has not competed with his neighbors to produce more support and rival his peers in strenuous military efforts. In defense of their religion they consider it a small thing to spend life and soul; and they have kept their infidel brothers supplied with arms and champions of war; and all they have done and all their generosity has been purely out of zeal for him they worship in jealous defense of their faith.

    “The Muslims on the other hand are weak and demoralized; they have become negligent and lazy, the victims of unproductive stupefaction and completely lacking in enthusiasm. If , Allah forbid, Islam should draw rein, obscure her splendor, blunt her sword, there would be no one, east or west, far or near who would blaze the zeal for Allah’s religion, or choose to come to the aid of truth against error.

    “This is the moment to cast off laziness, to summon from far and near all those men who have blood in their veins; but we are confident (he speaks about himself and the small party of believers who began with him and then became a large party); but we are confident, thanks to Allah-Alhamdulillah-in the Help that will come from him and entrust ourselves to him in sincerity of purpose and deepest devotion.

    “Insha Allah, the disbelievers shall perish and the faithful have a sure deliverance.”

    -Salahuddin Ayyubi 12 CE

  56. Haqq

    January 16, 2009 at 1:40 PM

    Allah knows better!
    Allah say’s jews not some of them but jews.

    Al-Fatiha [1:7] The Way of those on whom You have bestowed Your Grace, not (the way) of those who earned Your Anger (such as the jews), nor of those who went astray (such as the Christians).

    Al-Baqara [2:89] And when there came to them (the jews), a Book (this Qur’ân) from Allâh confirming what is with them [the Taurât (Torah) and the Injeel (Gospel)], although aforetime they had invoked Allâh (for coming of Muhammad Peace be upon him ) in order to gain victory over those who disbelieved, then when there came to them that which they had recognised, they disbelieved in it. So let the Curse of Allâh be on the disbelievers.

    Al-Baqara [2:96] And verily, you will find them (the jews) the greediest of mankind for life and (even greedier) than those who ascribe partners to Allâh (and do not believe in Resurrection – Majus, pagans, and idolaters). Everyone of them wishes that he could be given a life of a thousand years. But the grant of such life will not save him even a little from (due) punishment. And Allâh is All-Seer of what they do.

    Al-Baqara [2:120] Never will the jews nor the Christians be pleased with you (O Muhammad Peace be upon him ) till you follow their religion. Say: “Verily, the Guidance of Allâh (i.e. Islâmic Monotheism) that is the (only) Guidance. And if you (O Muhammad Peace be upon him ) were to follow their (jews and Christians) desires after what you have received of Knowledge (i.e. the Qur’ân), then you would have against Allâh neither any Walî (protector or guardian) nor any helper.

    Al-Baqara [2:65] And indeed you knew those amongst you who transgressed in the matter of the Sabbath (i.e. Saturday). We said to them: “Be you monkeys, despised and rejected.”

    Al-Maeda [5:60] Say (O Muhammad SAW to the people of the Scripture): “Shall I inform you of something worse than that, regarding the recompense from Allâh: those (Jews) who incurred the Curse of Allâh and His Wrath, those of whom (some) He transformed into monkeys and swines, those who worshipped Tâghût (false deities); such are worse in rank (on the Day of Resurrection in the Hell¬fire), and far more astray from the Right Path (in the life of this world).”

    Al-Araf [7:166] So when they exceeded the limits of what they were prohibited, We said to them: “Be you monkeys, despised and rejected.”

  57. salafFollower

    January 16, 2009 at 3:29 PM


    So you mean Salahuddin didn’t call for the tasfiyya and tarbiya of the Muslims, before calling them to action? He didn’t first ask them all to become students of knowledge studying at the feet of the scholars learning the detailed rulings of fiqh and chains of narrations?

    Indeed, his methodology was completely incorrect: calling the Muslims to action without knowledge, jihad without taqwa. Didn’t he realize that all that befell the muslims was due to their own sins? If only he would have been guided by the ulama and students of knowledge of our times he would have been on the true salafi manhaj. He would have been patient. He would have made sincere dua. He would have advised the lazy and corrupt rulers *in secret*. What was all this about inciting the people (steeped in sin) to action and causing fitna and strife for the rulers? Didn’t he know that the people have to be prepared *to deserve* the victory by working on themsleves and this can only be achieved by sitting on your musalla, saying istighfar, and learning the *knowledge*?

    Please stop bringing up references to Salahuddin. It seems he was not on the true Manhaj. We don’t want to take him as an example. We are peaceful people following a peaceful religion. We do not rely on worldy means for anything. All we need is true taqwa and true tawakkul and all our problems will be solved automatically in an instance. Go and sit at the feet of the scholars and learn some words of wisdom on how to get out of this mess. They have all the answers and all the solutions, if only we listened.

  58. Nur el Masih Ben Haq

    January 16, 2009 at 7:18 PM

    In response to comments on Gaza Massacre

    I have read most of your pro-Hamas comments and I have observed that Palestinians are largely innocent victims of those trying to impose Islam 100% in the Middle East and the Arab lands. Your blind pro-Hamas comments generally suggested that you are not really concerned about the massacre of the innocent Gazans; you are just interested in using them as sacrificial forces for pushing Islam. Those who want Palestinians to continue with the ‘Jihad’ or ‘Resistance’ in order to push Islam should also send their children (or go themselves) to fight Israel. Of course they should desire SHAHADA not only for the poor and innocent Palestinian children and civilians but for themselves and their children too, if they are sincere. I notice that even President Ahmadi Nejad or so of Iran, who had been advocating for the extermination of the state of Israel has not militarily supported the foolhardy Hamas. He has only been barking from a ‘safe’ distant position. If he is a sincere and serious anti-Zionist jihadist who wants to destroy Israel as he pretended to be, this is an opportunity for him to unleash Jihad on Israel since they are massacring his fellow Muslims. But the fact is that Ahmadi Nijad appeared eager to confront Israel just to impress the illiterate and gullible section of the umma (just as we have illiterate and gullible section of Ecclesia in Christianity). He never meant it. The children of most of these Hamas leaders are hidden in safe havens. Why don’t they want to die and go to Heaven like the children of less privileged Gazans? Why are they not eager to do SHAHADA?

    Look, like it or not; the Iranian-supported Hamas are the problem of Palestinians. The crime being committed by the Israeli military against the innocent civilians was engineered by Hamas by default. I don’t see what Hamas gains by this so-called resistance. What are they resisting any way? The occupation is not intelligently resisted; it is only ‘resisted’ in a crude, dangerous and fatal manner.
    Let me tell you one bitter truth: It would take mother of miracles for Hamas to prevail through her militant approach. So, they should stop giving the Jews excuses to kill innocent Palestinians only for them to be making empty threads. When Israel threatened to enter Gaza Hamas made outrageous noise but Israel entered and an iota of what Hamas threatened has not come to pass.

    After all the entire land of Israel is how much? The Arabs have over ten countries while the Jews have only one, a tiny area. So I believe the Jews have already designed a sophisticated means of retaining this tiny land. For them, it is a matter of life and death. So let us be realistic in our expectations. Let us encourage the Palestinians and their brethren Israel to negotiate objectively and realistically. But most importantly, these criminal killings of innocent gazans must stop right now!!!!!!!!!!!!!….Kill millions of Hamas if you want!

  59. Abu Abdurrahman

    January 16, 2009 at 8:04 PM

    Akhi ‘salaf0follower’ – may Allah bless you in this world and the Next, ameen!

    Brother, please do not let anyone encourage you to continue saying the type of comment as the one above. I know with full certainty that you say it with the bets of will and intention in this world – and I truely have no doubt about that, and upon Allah lies the ecision of all affairs; but my brother, I cannot help but feel, and I could be wrong, that it is in fact this type of comment which is in fact a statement/action without being preceded by knowledge of whether it’s correct or not.

    May Allah forgive and pardon us all.

    You are obviously totally right about many things such as the importance of sitting by the feet of the scholars and people of virtue etc. and of tarbiyyah upon tasfiyyah etc. and the solution lying in Islam. But perhaps you overlooked the reality of Salahuddeen, rahimahullah. It was a time, actually almost similar to ours in the sense, that the land(s) of Islam were being literally attacked. At that point, it is not a case of sitting down and exclusively doing the ta’leem of all aspects of the deen, as should usually be the case – but rather is one of acting upon the fara’id that are known to the best of one’s ability and aquainting one’s self as much as possible of what one is not aware; in brief: there is an agreement of the People of Knowledge that it then becomes binding on all those of ability in those lands and its surroundings to endure that they come to the physical defence of the lands of Islam. That is not a ‘incorrect methodolgy’ brother.

    As for other matters wherein Salahuddeen may have erred then that is obviously open to discussion, but by no means should that preclude someone being able to cite an example from his times, as long as it is correctly cited and interpretted and it is being used in tandem and in support of the clear message of how to revive the Deen, as per the guidance from Allah in the Quran and Sunnah. Allah knows best.

    I hope you did not take any offence to me saying any of the above bro.

    JazakumAllahu khairan for your eagerness to state the truth.

    Wassalamu alaykum wa rahmtullah

  60. Gazacaust-to salaf follower

    January 16, 2009 at 8:54 PM


    Brother Salaffollower you need help.

    The words of “advice” you are giving to others can HELP YOU the most, Insha’Allah.

    I am the slave of Allah swt and He guides me through sources and scholars youhave no knowledge of< I am sorry brother, I am NOT the slave of esteemed scholarly feet, no matter how good they smell.

    Your speech shows your Eemaan, people on this blog from your previous post know what I am talking about, may Allah have Mercy on your soul.

  61. salafFollower

    January 17, 2009 at 1:00 AM

    @Abu Abdurrahman

    Dear brothers,

    Please try to read a little bit more everyday so that you’re able to pick up sarcasm.


  62. Shah Faisal

    January 17, 2009 at 5:30 PM

    Another proof of point number 2 “Generalizing About an Entire Population “.

    Jewish British Lawmaker Likens Israel to Nazis

    Sir Gerald Kaufman, on Thursday 15 Jan 2009 compared the actions of Israeli troops in Gaza to the Nazis who forced his family to flee Poland. Sir Gerald, a member of the Jewish Labour movement linked to Prime Minister Gordon Brown’s ruling party, called for an arms embargo against Israel.

    Listen to Sir Gerald Kaufman’s speech on Video:

    http://www.informat ionclearinghouse .info/article217 81.htm com/watch? v=qMGuYjt6CP8

    Read the text of Sir Gerald Kaufman’s Parliamentary Speech:
    15 Jan 2009 : Column 407

    http://www.publicat ions.parliament. uk/pa/cm200809/ cmhansrd/ cm090115/ debtext/90115- 0013.htm

  63. Haqq

    January 18, 2009 at 5:36 PM

    Some of you guys really got some issues. “Salahudeen Ayubi was not on the right manhaj” … whoa big words, yeah right and you are on the right manhaj?

    “Go and study under the feet of the scholars because they have the solution”…what a contradiction of Qur’an and the Sunnah, you got real issues to deal with. If I was you I would just refrain from typing or speaking because the nonsense that is coming out of you is beyond anything I know.

    -pls refrain from copy-posting long list of verses. -edited

  64. Qas

    January 18, 2009 at 5:52 PM

    Haqq…he was being sarcastic. Read his blurb a post before yours.

  65. Em Ahmad

    January 18, 2009 at 6:52 PM

    Mashallah, nicely documented article – especially regarding socio-political factors.

    My sole comment is (and I do not mean this in the callous way some people have emotionally put it throughout this comment section) that every “israeli” Jew living in Palestine IS an occupier. While they may be against further expansion into what is now referred to as Palestinian territories, their very presence makes them an occupier by definition. In order to lose that moniker they would have to move, as I personally know many Jews to have done in protest. I have met many Jews who had immigrated to “Israel” only to give up their citizenship in protest after what they witnessed and move to the US or elsewhere. You will find many of them in the protest marches, and they feel that any self-respecting Jew should renounce their israeli citizenship and leave its illegally formed borders.

    That point aside, this is one of the best researched and documented articles written by a Muslim in quite some time, mashallah. I was actually able to read it to the end without clicking on something else. Important lessons for all!

  66. Algebra

    January 18, 2009 at 9:22 PM

    1.Since we are out of the Emergency Room(CRISIS, Genocide, war) now and placed in the ICU(Cease fire). What do we need to do now to get to better and stronger health?
    This is my question for Dr. Ali Shehata. I have great RESPECT for your ADVICE.

    2. Umm Reem has written about helping some families of Gaza in the recuperation process through CAIR. Something to look at for those of us who can give more than our 2 1/2 %


  67. Pingback: Open Thread Sunday 1/25/09 |

  68. S

    January 28, 2010 at 2:41 PM

    excellent article mashaAllah!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *