Connect with us


A Nightmare World of Torture and Prison Guard Suicides


A good look at some of the conditions inside Guantanamo.

Confessions of a Gitmo Guard


A psychiatrist who has treated former military personnel at Guantánamo prison camp is telling a story of prisoner torture and guard suicide there, recounted to him by a National Guardsman who worked at Guantánamo just after it opened.

Dr. John R. Smith, 75, is a Oklahoma City psychiatrist who has done worked at military posts during the past few years. He is also a consultant for the University of Oklahoma’s Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Services, and is affiliated with the Veteran’s Affairs Administration Hospital in Oklahoma City. The court-appointed psychiatric examination of Timothy McVeigh, who bombed the Murrah Federal Building in 1995, was conducted by Smith. A few years ago, he became a contract physician, treating active duty members of the US military in need of psychotherapy.

Smith spoke on February 22, 2008, at the annual meeting of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences, held in Washington DC. His presentation dealt with the psychological impact on guards of working at Guantánamo . He focused on a chilling case history, of a patient he called “Mr. H.”

Smith described Mr. H as a blue-collar Latino in his 40s who had done routine service in the National Guard for years before being called up to Kuwait. Then, shortly after 9/11, he was diverted from Kuwait to Guantánamo . The detention camp had just opened. Mr. H was deployed there to work as a guard.

Untrained for the job, Mr. H was taken aback by the detainees. They threw feces and urine on him, said Smith, and tried to get him to sneak letters out, telling him that if he didn’t, “they would see to it that his family suffered the consequences.” The prisoners also mocked Mr. H, that his being in the military made him “a traitor” to Latinos and other minorities. Mr. H was confused and terrified.

Meanwhile, according to Smith, “this good Catholic man with a family who had pretty much always followed the rules” was called on to participate in torture. One of his jobs was “to take detainees to certain places and see that they were handcuffed in difficult positions, usually naked, in anticipation of interrogation.” Mr. H often watched the questioning. He saw prisoners pushed until they fell down, then cut. They responded to the torture with “defecation, vomiting, urinating,” and “psychotic reactions: bizarre screaming and crying.”

Smith noted that Mr. H said he was “required to handcuff and push to the ground detainees who were naked.” The prisoners were also made to “remain on sharp stones on their knees.” Detainees, Mr. H told Smith, would try to avoid interrogation by rubbing their knees until they bled in order be taken to the prison hospital.

According to Smith, Mr. H’s comment about these events “was poignant and simple: ‘It was wrong what we did.'” While still at Guantánamo , he responded to being a participant in torture “with guilt, crying and tears. But of course it was forbidden to talk with anyone about what he was experiencing.” He “became more and more depressed.” Apparently, so did other military personnel. Smith said Mr. H told him that in the first month he was at Guantánamo , two guards committed suicide.

Smith said that by the time he saw Mr. H, he “had become very ill. He was suicidal, terribly depressed, anxious,” and “riddled with insomnia and horrible dreams and flashbacks.” He had already seen two military therapists and not improved. But those therapists “were active duty and he didn’t dare tell them” what had happened at Guantánamo . Smith was not active duty, and after two or three sessions Mr. H opened up. With medication and psychotherapy, he became less suicidal but was still too sick to do any more military service.

Three years later after treating Mr. H, Smith got three new patients who were guards at Guantánamo on later tours. They said conditions were much improved –“they loved it at Guantánamo and went swimming in the Caribbean.” Still, one guard was having problems directly related to his work there. He “described having to cut down a detainee” who tried to hang himself after chewing through an artery in his own arm. There was blood everywhere. When the guard left Guantánamo , he was suffering from “anxiety attacks, panic attacks.”

Smith said his presentation at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting was the first time he’d ever spoken publicly about his Guantánamo patients. He decided to talk, he said, because he is concerned that veterans are generally ineligible for PTSD (post-traumatic stress disorder) disability benefits if the condition is not caused by combat. He considers the guards of Guantánamo “an overlooked group of victims.” But in making that case, Smith stepped into a unique role. Heretofore, almost all accounts of torture at Guantánamo have come from non-governmental human rights groups or detainees and their defense lawyers. The FBI accounts in 2004 were contradictory. Smith, a prestigious physician, relayed accounts from inside the military.

Please see related posts,

Keep supporting MuslimMatters for the sake of Allah

Alhamdulillah, we're at over 850 supporters. Help us get to 900 supporters this month. All it takes is a small gift from a reader like you to keep us going, for just $2 / month.

The Prophet (SAW) has taught us the best of deeds are those that done consistently, even if they are small. Click here to support MuslimMatters with a monthly donation of $2 per month. Set it and collect blessings from Allah (swt) for the khayr you're supporting without thinking about it.

Omar Usman is a founding member of MuslimMatters and Qalam Institute. He teaches Islamic seminars across the US including Khateeb Workshop and Fiqh of Social Media. He has served in varying administrative capacities for multiple national and local Islamic organizations. You can follow his work at



  1. theManOfFewWords

    March 18, 2008 at 11:23 AM

    Subhanallah, and Muslims are the ones being called barbaric. Long beards and turbans are the very symbol of backwardness in the West and even in many Muslim countries.

    But it’s the sharks in three piece suits that are the true barbarians.

    I would like to see the Islamophobic hypocrites compare a video of a beheading with a torture session in Guantanamo and see what disgusts them more.

  2. Dawud Israel

    March 18, 2008 at 12:25 PM

    Subhana Allah…

    The nature of evil is that it destroys itself.

  3. aiabgold

    March 18, 2008 at 12:41 PM

    Beautiful comment Dawud.

  4. Abu Noor Al-Irlandee

    March 18, 2008 at 3:08 PM

    “Try and separate a man from his soul
    You’ll only strengthen him and lose your own”

    Brother Ali, “Uncle Sam G-ddamn”

  5. Malik

    March 18, 2008 at 7:37 PM

    except for the fact that security is not handled by national guardsmen in Gitmo. This story is a lie on it’s face.

    I mean, come on, Counterpunch? That’s looney bin territory.

  6. Asad

    March 18, 2008 at 11:59 PM

    Great article- it definitely provides food for thought. One quibble and it has to deal with grammar. The following sentence, “Dr. John R. Smith, 75, is a Oklahoma City psychiatrist who has done worked at military posts during the past few years” should not say “done worked” but instead should say “worked.”

  7. Abu Noor Al-Irlandee

    March 19, 2008 at 9:48 AM


    I don’t know if you’re comment was supposed to be sarcastic or something, but in case anyone’s as confused as I was by it, here’s a press release from the National Guard Association of the U.S. in 2002 talking about the deployment of an MP Brigade to Guantanamo.

  8. Yankee Doodle

    March 23, 2008 at 3:34 PM

    “But it’s the sharks in three piece suits that are the true barbarians.”

    There’s a great deal of truth in that statement.

    “I would like to see the Islamophobic hypocrites compare a video of a beheading with a torture session in Guantanamo and see what disgusts them more.”

    I condemn it all.

    In fact, I am in the process of condemning it all with a three-part series at my blog addressing Abu Ghraib.

  9. Pingback: Who Speaks for Islam? Part 3a- What Makes a Radical? |

  10. Pingback: Religious (non-Physical) Torture at Guantanamo |

  11. Pingback: You learn so much from Watching Fox news - Page 4 - - Mercedes Benz Discussion Forum

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *